Skip to Content

Sauce Makeover: 5 BEST Alfredo Sauce Substitutes

Okay, so you’re looking to shake up your pasta game, right? We’ve got what you need.

Alfredo sauce is great and all, but sometimes, you just want to switch things up without losing that creamy, dreamy vibe.

You’re searching for alternatives that still bring the cozy, but maybe with a twist or a healthier spin. And guess what?

We’ve scoured kitchens and cookbooks to serve up five absolutely slamming Alfredo substitutes.

These aren’t your everyday sauces; they’re game-changers.

From veggie-packed wonders to nutty delights, we promise there’s something here that’ll make your spaghetti sing. Ready to dig in?

The 5 BEST & Healthy Substitutes for Alfredo Sauce

If you’re looking for a healthier alternative to your favorite Alfredo sauce, you’ve come to the right place.

We’ve rounded up five tasty and nutritious substitutes that will help make your dish more wholesome without sacrificing flavor.

You can use these alternatives in any dish that calls for Alfredo sauce and enjoy a delicious meal without guilt.

1 – Greek yogurt

Greek yogurt has surged in popularity over the past several years, becoming a favorite in many households.

The origins of Greek yogurt are quite mysterious; it is believed to have been created by either ancient Greeks or Turkish shepherds.

It is made using regular milk, which is then strained through a cheesecloth-lined sieve to remove the whey and thicken it up.

The result is a velvety-smooth, creamy texture and tart citrus-like taste that even non-yogurt fans find deliciously addictive.

It can be used to make smoothies, dips, and even as a substitute for Alfredo sauce in pasta dishes – just stir some Greek yogurt into your favorite Alfredo sauce recipe for an added zing.

2 – Cauliflower Alfredo Sauce

Making Alfredo sauce with cauliflower? It sounds strange, but this dish can be a delicious and nutritious alternative to regular Alfredo.

Although the idea of adding cauliflower to Alfredo is relatively new, it has been gaining in popularity due to its exceptionally creamy consistency.

Making the sauce is quite simple – all you have to do is boil and mash some cauliflower, add it to a food processor along with garlic, butter, cream cheese, and salt, then blend until smooth.

The resulting sauce offers an explosion of flavors while being surprisingly low in calories.

Moreover, due to its mild taste and light texture, it works deliciously as a substitute for traditional Alfredo in pasta dishes without sacrificing flavor.

3 – Cashew Cream Sauce

Cashew cream sauce is an ultra-creamy and delicious plant-based alternative to Alfredo sauce.

Originating from India, cashew cream sauce is a simple blend of roasted cashews, garlic, salt, pepper, and vegan broth or water.

It’s perfect for any pasta dish as it appears very similar to Alfredo in flavor, but it carries a much lighter taste.

Its flavor is subtle yet satisfying, and its velvety texture works perfectly to coat your noodles evenly.

You can easily swap out Alfredo for the cashew cream sauce in just about any recipe without losing its creamy consistency or delicious taste.

It’s simple to make and can elevate your favorite Italian dishes in no time.

4 – Olive Oil Alfredo Sauce

Making your own Olive Oil Alfredo Sauce at home can be surprisingly easy and enjoyable.

It originates from the Italian region of Liguria, where people use their own unique combination of local herbs, dairy, cheese, and Olive oil to achieve its authentic flavor.

Olive Oil Alfredo Sauce combines a subtle flavor bursting with a creamy texture complemented with savory Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese.

To follow its signature taste, it’s best to use the freshest olive oil available directly from a local source.

You can easily substitute Original Alfredo sauce with this delightfully tempting alternative in different recipes such as Fettuccine Alfredo or Chicken Alfredo for a healthier and lighter version as – promise it won’t let you down.

5 – Vegan Cheese Sauce

Vegan cheese sauces make it effortless to follow a dairy-free diet without missing out on cheesy favorites.

While vegan substitutes are becoming an increasingly popular trend, vegan cheese sauce has taken the culinary world by storm.

Traditional varieties of this creamy concoction usually involve replacing dairy ingredients with plant-based counterparts like nuts, seeds, and coconut milk to achieve a smooth and creamy consistency.

For example, one version of vegan cheese sauce replaces cow’s milk with cashews, nutritional yeast for the savory cheese flavor, garlic and onion powder for the pungent elements, and thickened with potato starch or tapioca flour for the perfect thickness.

The result is a delicious sauce that not only tastes similar to traditional alfredo sauce but provides all the same health benefits that come along with plant-based ingredients.

It’s also very versatile; in addition to topping off your favorite pasta dishes, vegan cheese sauces can be used as dips or sliced up onto nachos or veggie burgers.

Making the switch is easier than you might think; simply replace traditional recipes using alfredo sauce with its dairy-free alternative.

Sauce Makeover: 5 BEST Alfredo Sauce Substitutes

Looking to switch up your Alfredo sauce game? Dive into our selection of the best substitutes that offer creamy, flavorful alternatives to the classic recipe.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Greek yogurt
  • Cauliflower Alfredo Sauce
  • Cashew Cream Sauce
  • Olive Oil Alfredo Sauce
  • Vegan Cheese Sauce


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword Healthy Substitutes for Alfredo Sauce
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating