Skip to Content

Flavorful Choices: 5 Best American Cheese Substitutes

Look, finding a stand-in for American cheese isn’t a walk in the park.

We’re here to guide you through it, easy-peasy. Sure, American cheese has its charm in burgers and sandwiches.

Yet, sometimes we crave a twist. Maybe it’s about health choices or simply shaking things up in the kitchen.

We’ve got your back with five stellar alternatives that’ll keep your dishes exciting. No more same-old, same-old.

Trust us, these substitutes are game changers. You’re about to transform your meals from good to “can I have seconds?”

The 5 Best Substitutes for American Cheese

American cheese, known for its creamy and mild flavor, is a popular choice for sandwiches, burgers, and grilled cheese.

However, if you are looking for alternatives to American cheese or cannot find it, there are several substitutes available.

In this guide, we will compare the top 5 substitutes for American cheese, discussing their key characteristics and suggesting proper ratios to help you find suitable alternatives.

SubstituteKey CharacteristicsProper Ratio
Cheddar CheeseA sharp and tangy cheese with a creamy texture, commonly used in sandwiches and meltsUse an equal amount of cheddar cheese as a substitute for American cheese
Colby CheeseA mild and slightly sweet cheese with a softer texture, often blended with cheddar cheeseUse an equal amount of colby cheese as a substitute for American cheese
Muenster CheeseA semi-soft cheese with a mild and buttery flavor, known for its superior melting propertiesUse an equal amount of muenster cheese as a substitute for American cheese
Velveeta CheeseA processed cheese product with a creamy and velvety texture, ideal for melting and saucesUse an equal amount of Velveeta cheese as a substitute for American cheese
Monterey Jack CheeseA mild and slightly tangy cheese with a smooth and creamy texture, versatile for various dishes and meltsUse an equal amount of Monterey Jack cheese as a substitute for American cheese

Now, let’s explore each substitute in more detail:

1 – Cheddar Cheese

cheddar cheese

While cheddar cheese is often considered a distinctly British food, its origins are pretty murky.

The first recorded use of the word “cheddar” dates back to the 12th century, but it’s unclear whether this refers to the village in Somerset, England, or the cheese produced there.

What is known is that cheddar cheese was being made in the Cheddar Gorge by the 15th century, and its popularity soon spread throughout the country.

Today, cheddar cheese is one of the most popular types of cheese globally, and it’s used in a wide variety of dishes.

Whether it’s melted on a grilled cheese sandwich or sprinkled on top of a salad, cheddar cheese adds a delicious sharpness to any meal.

  • Key Characteristics: Cheddar cheese offers a sharp and tangy flavor, along with a creamy texture. It is a versatile cheese commonly used in sandwiches and melts.
  • Proper Ratio: Use an equal amount of cheddar cheese as a substitute for American cheese. Adjust the quantity based on personal preference and desired level of sharpness.

2 – Colby Cheese

colby cheese

Colby cheese is a type of American cheese characterized by its firm texture and mild flavor.

It is made using a washed-curd method, which involves adding an acidic solution to the milk before curdling it—this process washes away some of the whey, resulting in lower lactose content.

Colby cheese is often used in grilled cheese sandwiches and quesadillas, as its flavor pairs well with both savory and sweet toppings.

It is also a popular choice for macaroni and cheese, as its firm texture holds up well to boiling.

  • Key Characteristics: Colby cheese has a mild and slightly sweet flavor with a softer texture. It is often blended with cheddar cheese.
  • Proper Ratio: Use an equal amount of colby cheese as a substitute for American cheese. Adjust the quantity based on personal preference and desired flavor balance.

3 – Muenster Cheese

muenster cheese

The rich and creamy flavor of Muenster cheese makes it a favorite among cheese lovers.

This French cheese is made from cow’s milk and has a soft and smooth texture.

The yellowish-orange color of Muenster cheese comes from annatto, a natural food coloring.

Muenster cheese is often used in grilled cheese sandwiches, as its mild flavor pairs well with other ingredients.

It is also a popular choice for macaroni and cheese.

In addition to its excellent taste, Muenster cheese is also a good source of calcium and protein.

  • Key Characteristics: Muenster cheese is a semi-soft cheese with a mild and buttery flavor. It is known for its superior melting properties, making it an excellent choice for sandwiches and melts.
  • Proper Ratio: Use an equal amount of muenster cheese as a substitute for American cheese. Adjust the quantity based on personal preference and desired level of creaminess.

4 – Velveeta Cheese

velveeta cheese

Velveeta cheese is a processed cheese product that was introduced in 1928.

It is made from milk, whey, and sodium phosphate and has a smooth, creamy texture.

Velveeta is often used as a dip or a spread and can also be melted and used as a sauce or in recipes.

One of the best things about Velveeta cheese is that it never hardens or spoils, making it a convenient pantry staple.

However, some people find the taste of Velveeta to be too rich or salty.

Others worry about the health effects of consuming processed foods.

Overall, though, Velveeta cheese is a delicious and versatile food that millions of people have enjoyed.

  • Key Characteristics: Velveeta cheese is a processed cheese product renowned for its creamy and velvety texture. It is ideal for melting and creating smooth sauces.
  • Proper Ratio: Use an equal amount of Velveeta cheese as a substitute for American cheese. Adjust the quantity based on personal preference and desired creaminess.

5 – Monterey Jack Cheese

monterey jack cheese

Monterey Jack cheese is a type of cheese that originated in Central America.

It is made from cow’s milk and has a mild, buttery taste.

Monterey Jack cheese is often used in Mexican and Tex-Mex dishes, and it can also be shredded and used as a topping on salads or pizzas.

One of the most popular brands of Monterey Jack cheese is “Jacks,” which is produced by the California Cheese Company.

Jack’s cheese is available in several varieties, including regular, sharp, and jalapeno.

  • Key Characteristics: Monterey Jack cheese offers a mild and slightly tangy flavor with a smooth and creamy texture. It is a versatile cheese suitable for various dishes, including melts.
  • Proper Ratio: Use an equal amount of Monterey Jack cheese as a substitute for American cheese. Adjust the quantity based on personal preference and desired level of tanginess.

The 5 Best Substitutes for American Cheese

Searching for alternatives to American cheese? Your quest ends here! Explore our curated list of the 5 best substitutes that will seamlessly replace American cheese in your recipes, ensuring a delightful twist to your culinary creations.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving

Ingredients
  

  • Cheddar Cheese
  • Colby Cheese
  • Muenster Cheese
  • Velveeta Cheese
  • Monterey Jack Cheese

Instructions
 

  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword substitutes for american cheese
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating