Skip to Content

Amish Paste vs Roma Totatoes: What’s the Difference?

Are you struggling to decide between Roma and Amish Paste tomatoes? If yes, this guide is specially designed for you.

We will discuss the differences between these two popular types of tomato and help you choose the right one for your meal.

So, don’t worry – we’ve got you covered.

What are Amish Paste Tomatoes?

Amish Paste Tomatoes are a type of tomato that is known for its size and flavor.

These tomatoes have a meaty texture and a sweet taste, making them perfect for use in sauces, salsas, and other dishes.

They were originally developed by the Amish community in the United States.

If you’re looking for a tomato that can be used in a variety of recipes, Amish Paste Tomatoes are an excellent choice.

They are versatile and can be used in everything from soups to sandwiches to salads.

They also have a long shelf life, making them a great option if you want to stock up on tomatoes.

When it comes to growing Amish Paste Tomatoes, they require similar conditions to other tomato varieties.

They prefer full sun exposure and well-drained soil.

It’s important to water them regularly but not overwater as this can lead to root rot.

In terms of harvesting Amish Paste Tomatoes, they should be picked when they are fully ripe and have turned deep red.

If you leave them on the vine too long, they may become overripe which can affect their flavor.

What are Roma Tomatoes?

Roma tomatoes, also known as plum tomatoes, are a type of tomato that is commonly used in Italian cuisine.

These tomatoes are prized for their meaty texture and low water content, making them ideal for use in sauces, stews, and other dishes where a thick consistency is desired.

When it comes to flavor, Roma tomatoes have a mild taste that is slightly sweet.

They are often used as a base for pasta sauces and salsas, as they can be cooked down without losing their shape or texture.

In terms of color, Roma tomatoes are generally bright red in hue and have a glossy appearance when ripe.

Overall, Roma tomatoes are known for being versatile and easy to work with in the kitchen.

Whether you’re using them in soups or salads, these tomatoes can add both texture and nutrition to your meals.

Differences Between Amish Paste Tomatoes and Roma Tomatoes

The Amish Paste Tomato is more oblong or egg-shaped, while the Roma Tomato is oval or cylindrical in shape.

In terms of taste, the Amish Paste Tomato has a sweet flavor with rich aroma and lower acidity compared to other types of paste tomatoes.

The Roma Tomato, on the other hand, has a mildly tart taste with high acidity which makes it an ideal ingredient for many Italian dishes such as pasta sauces.

When it comes to texture, the Amish Paste Tomato is firmer and meatier compared to other paste tomato varieties.

It’s less watery too which means that it’s perfect for creating a great salsa as well as slicing up for salads.

The Roma Tomato too has a dense texture that’s relatively dry, making it an ideal ingredient for canning as well as making sauces or pastes.

Origin and History

To start with, both Amish Paste Tomatoes and Roma Tomatoes are heirloom varieties of tomatoes that have been widely cultivated in different parts of the world for centuries.

The origin of Amish Paste Tomatoes can be traced back to Eastern Europe, where they were grown by the Amish community for their paste-making abilities.

In contrast, Roma Tomatoes were first developed in Italy during the early 20th century.

Despite not knowing its origin and historical use clearly, it is believed that Amish communities brought over these plant varieties as they migrated from Europe to America in the late 19th century.

Meanwhile, Roma tomatoes gained popularity in Italian cuisine after being developed in Italy during the early 20th century.

Since then, they have grown popular worldwide as commercial farms looking for alternative tomato breeds took over.

All-in-all, while Amish Paste Tomatoes have an unclear origin, Roma tomatoes come with a clearer story behind them that tells us how they became so widely recognized within Italian cooking practices.

Appearance and Size

When it comes to the appearance and size of the Amish Paste Tomato and Roma Tomato, there are some noticeable differences.

While both varieties have similarities in their shape and sizes, there are small differences that set them apart.

The Amish Paste Tomatoes tend to be larger than Romas and have a blockier shape with more pronounced points – probably why they’re referred to as paste tomatoes.

The Roma is elongated, almost football-shaped, and has a smooth texture all around.

Appearance and size do not determine the flavor or texture of a tomato, but they can impact your gardening preferences or recipe selection.

Flavor and Texture

When it comes to flavor and texture, both the Amish Paste Tomato and the Roma have distinct characteristics.

Let’s take a closer look at each variety.

In terms of flavor, the Amish Paste Tomato tends to be sweeter and less acidic than the Roma.

This makes it an excellent choice for those who enjoy a mild yet flavorful tomato taste in their sauces or salsas.

On the other hand, some people find the Roma’s tangier taste appealing when eaten raw or used as an ingredient in dishes.

Regarding texture, the Amish Paste offers thick and meaty flesh with fewer seeds than Romas.

Therefore, it is well-suited for canning or using in sauces where texture matters more than taste.

On the other hand, even though Romas have denser flesh with more seeds compared to Amish paste tomatoes, they maintain their firmness, making them ideal ingredients for salads or sandwiches.

All in all, both types of tomatoes have distinct flavor profiles and textures that cater to different preferences.

While Amish Paste is a good choice for preserving and cooking applications, Roma Tomatoes are best when used raw or lightly cooked to retain their texture.

Suitability for Different Uses

When it comes to choosing between the Amish Paste tomato and Roma tomato, it’s important to consider their suitability for different uses.

As you can see, Amish Paste tomatoes are better suited for making thick sauces and paste while Roma tomatoes are great for making regular sauces and are also excellent for canning.

When it comes to using tomatoes in sandwiches, the juicy texture of Roma tomatoes makes them a better choice than the dense Amish Paste.

The suitability of these two varieties for different uses ultimately depends on your taste preferences and cooking needs.

If you prefer a thicker sauce or paste, opt for the Amish Paste.

On the other hand, if you plan on using the tomatoes for canning or making regular sauce, go with Roma.

Consider how you will be using these tomatoes before deciding which one to grow in your garden or purchase at the store.

Whether it’s thick sauces or salads, there is a suitable tomato out there for every recipe.

In summary, knowing the best use of both tomatoes helps you make an informed decision based on your own preference.

Growing and Harvesting Differences

When it comes to growing and harvesting Amish Paste tomatoes versus Roma tomatoes, there are several differences to consider.

Let’s take a closer look at some key factors.

To start with, both varieties of tomatoes can be grown in similar conditions.

They require warm weather, plenty of sunlight, and well-draining soil.

However, Amish Paste plants tend to produce larger fruit than Roma plants.

This means that they require more space to grow, so you should plan accordingly when planting your garden.

Another difference between the two types of tomato is the time it takes for them to mature.

On average, Amish Paste tomatoes take longer to reach maturity than Roma tomatoes.

This means that you may need to wait a little longer before you can begin harvesting your crop.

When it comes to harvesting, there are some differences between these two varieties as well.

For example, Amish Paste tomatoes tend to have thicker skins than Roma tomatoes.

This makes them more durable and less likely to crack during harvest.

However, their thicker skins can also make them more difficult to peel if you plan on using them for sauces or other recipes that require skinless flesh.

Overall, understanding the growing and harvesting differences between Amish Paste and Roma tomatoes can help you make an informed decision when choosing which variety to plant in your garden.

Popular Brands of Amish Paste and Roma Tomatoes

When it comes to popular tomato varieties, Amish Paste and Roma tomatoes are always at the forefront.

Both these tomatoes have great taste and texture, which makes them a favorite among many people.

While there are other tomato varieties available, these two stand out from the rest due to their unique features.

Let’s take a closer look at some of the popular brands for both Amish Paste and Roma tomatoes.

As you can see, there are many options when it comes to buying either Amish Paste or Roma tomatoes.

Whether you prefer organic seeds or plant varieties from established seed companies, there is something for everyone.

When choosing between these two types of tomatoes, it all boils down to your personal preference.

Some people believe that Amish Paste has a sweeter taste than Roma, while others find that Roma has a more robust flavor profile.

Ultimately, it depends on what type of dish you’re making and how you like your tomatoes.

It’s always best to experiment with both varieties and see what works best for your palate.

With so many excellent brands available in the market, you’re sure to find one that suits your taste buds perfectly.


As we conclude, it is clear that both the Amish Paste and Roma tomatoes have their unique features.

It is important to note that both types of tomatoes are versatile and can be used in a variety of ways in the kitchen.

The choice between using Amish Paste or Roma will depend on the specific recipe requirements or personal taste preferences.

Amish Paste vs Roma Totatoes: What’s the Difference?

Intrigued by tomatoes and their varieties? Differentiate between Amish Paste and Roma tomatoes to grasp their unique characteristics, from taste and texture to ideal culinary uses.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That
Servings 1 Serving


  • Amish Paste
  • Roma Totatoes


  • Choose between two items based on your preference and availability.
  • Follow the cooking directions for your chosen option, using the appropriate ratio of ingredients.
  • Prepare it according to your desired recipes.
  • Incorporate them into your dish, adjusting the amount to suit your taste.
  • Enjoy the unique taste experience and experiment with different dishes to explore their versatility.
Keyword Amish Paste vs Roma Totatoes
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating