Skip to Content

The 5 Best Substitutes for Apple Jelly

Do you love the taste of apple jelly? It’s a great way to enjoy the flavor of apples in a virulent form.

Making your apple jelly is easy, and it tastes so much better than store-bought.

The key to making good apple jelly is to use a variety of apples.

That way, you’ll get a nice balance of sweetness and tartness.

If you’ve never made jelly before, don’t worry. It’s not difficult.

The hardest part is waiting for the jelly to set up.

Once you’ve made your first batch of apple jelly, you’ll be hooked.

You’ll want to make it every fall when apples are in season.

Apple jelly is perfect if you’re looking for a delicious, versatile spread to top your toast, put in your yogurt, or add to your baking recipes.

But what do you do if you run out of apple jelly or don’t have time to make some yourself? Check out these five substitutes that will bring the taste of autumn to your table.

What is Apple Jelly?

what is apple jelly

Apple jelly is a fruit spread typically made from apples and sugar.

It can be used as a condiment or ingredient in various recipes.

While apple jelly is generally made from whole apples, some recipes may call for the use of apple cider or pureed apples.

The sugar content in apple jelly can vary depending on the recipe, but it is typically quite high.

As a result, many people view apple jelly as a treat or dessert rather than an everyday food.

Apple jelly should have a smooth texture and a deep red color when made correctly.

The taste of apple jelly is sweet and slightly tart, with the flavor of apples being the dominant taste.

There are several different ways to cook with apple jelly.

It can be used as a filling for pies or pastries or topping for pancakes or waffles.

Apple jelly can also be used in savory dishes, such as pork chops glazed with apple jelly.

No matter how you choose to use it, apple jelly is a delicious and versatile ingredient.

If you’ve never tried apple jelly before, I highly recommend giving it a try.

It’s a unique flavor that can enhance both sweet and savory dishes.

And, it’s a great way to enjoy the taste of apples all year round.

Thanks for reading, and I hope you found this post informative.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Apple Jelly

For those of you who cannot eat apple jelly or don’t like the taste, there are several excellent substitutes available.

Below, I’ve listed the five best substitutes for apple jelly and a brief description of each.

1. Canned Peaches

canned peaches

Canned peaches are often an overlooked item on grocery store shelves.

Often relegated to the back of the pantry, they often get lost behind cereal boxes and rice bags.

However, canned peaches can be a versatile and delicious ingredient in several recipes.

For example, they can be used to make apple jelly or added to jam for a unique flavor.

They can also be stirred into yogurt or oatmeal for a quick and easy breakfast.

And when compared to fresh peaches, canned peaches are often more affordable and easier to find year-round.

This makes them a great option for those who want to enjoy the taste of summer all year long.

When it comes to flavor, canned peaches are very similar to apples.

They are sweet with a hint of acidity, and their flesh is soft and easy to mash.

This makes them a good choice for recipes that call for apple jelly or applesauce.

Canned peaches can also be used in place of fresh apples in pies, crisps, and other baked goods.

And because they are already peeled and cut into pieces, they save time and effort when it comes to preparation.

2. Apple Juice

apple juice

Apple juice is a popular drink enjoyed by people of all ages.

It’s made by pressing apples to extract the juice, and it can be either sweet or tart, depending on the type of apple used.

Many people enjoy drinking apple juice on its own, but it’s also a common ingredient in cocktails and other drinks.

While apple juice is often consumed on its own, it can also be used in cooking.

For example, apple jelly is a preserve made with apple juice as the primary ingredient.

Apple juice can also be used as a natural sweetener in baked goods or a glaze for meats and vegetables.

If you’re looking for a substitute for apple jelly, apple juice is a good option.

It has a similar sweetness and can be used in many same ways.

Just keep in mind that it won’t have the same firm texture as jelly, so it may not work well in some recipes.

When shopping for apple juice, it’s important to check the labels carefully.

Some brands of apple juice are processed with added sugar or other sweeteners, so be sure to choose one that suits your needs.

3. Grape Jelly

grape jelly

Grape jelly is a delicious and versatile condiment.

It can be used on toast, in PB&Js, or even as a filling for cakes and cookies.

But what exactly is grape jelly, and how does it compare to other types of jelly?

This jelly is made from crushing and boiling grapes, then straining out the solids.

The resulting liquid is boiled again with sugar and pectin, which helps the jelly set.

Some recipes also call for adding lemon juice, which helps balance out the sweetness of the grapes.

It has a deep purple color and a slightly tart flavor.

It is also the most popular type of jelly in the United States.

Grape jelly is so popular that it is often used as a generic term for any jelly.

Texture-wise, grape jelly is smooth and spreadable.

It can also be used as a glaze for meats or a filling for pies and pastries.

You can usually find grape jelly in the grocery store near the other types of jelly.

It is often sold in plastic squeeze bottles or small jars.

4. Marmalade


Crafting the perfect marmalade can be a bit of an art form.

After all, there’s much more to it than simply dumping some fruit into a pot and boiling it down until it’s thick.

The key is to strike the right balance of acidity and sweetness and find the right ratio of fruit to sugar.

And of course, you need to start with good quality fruit in the first place.

With all of this in mind, it’s no wonder that many people prefer to leave the task of making a marmalade to the experts.

However, this doesn’t mean that you can’t make your marmalade at home.

In fact, with a little patience and practice, anyone can create a delicious batch of marmalade.

The key is to start with a good recipe and then to experiment until you find the perfect combination of ingredients for your taste.

For substituting Apple Jelly with marmalade, you need to consider the fact that marmalade is a bit more tart than Apple Jelly.

You may want to add a little extra sugar to your recipe when using marmalade as a substitute.

5. Apricot Jam

apricot jam

Apricot jam is a type of fruit preserve made from apricots.

It is similar to apple jelly, but it has a more distinct flavor compared to apple jelly.

Apricot jam can be made with just apricots and sugar, including other ingredients like lemon juice or spices.

It is often used as a filling for pies and pastries or as a spread for toast and muffins.

While it can be store-bought, apricot jam is also relatively easy to make at home.

The key to making a good batch of apricot jam is to use ripe apricots so that the jam has a deep flavor.

Once made, the apricot jam will last for several months when stored in a cool, dark place.

Apricot jam can be used in the same way as apple jelly and will still provide the same level of sweetness.

The other main difference is that apple jelly is made with apple juice while the apricot jam is made with apricot puree.

This means that apricot jam will have a higher fruit content.

When substituting, keep this in mind and adjust the amount of sugar accordingly.


Though apple jelly is a classic flavor, it can be hard to find in stores.

And when you do find it, it’s often expensive.

Luckily, a few easy substitutes can give you the same taste for a fraction of the price.

A marmalade is a great option, as it is both tart and sweet.

You can also try apricot jam, which has a similar texture to apple jelly and is also high in sugar.

If you’re looking for something even closer to apple jelly, try mixing equal parts apple juice and grape jelly.

Though it won’t be quite the same, this homemade option will be delicious and much more budget-friendly.

Yield: 1 Serving

The 5 Best Substitutes for Apple Jelly

The 5 Best Substitutes for Apple Jelly
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes


  • Canned Peaches
  • Apple Juice
  • Grape Jelly
  • Marmalade
  • Apricot Jam


  1. Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  2. Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
    Skip to Recipe