Skip to Content

Enhance Recipes: 5 BEST Substitutes for Blood Orange

Picture this: You’re all set to create that stunning dish, only to realize you’re out of blood oranges.

Now, that could put a real damper on things, right? Nope.

Think of this as your chance to mix things up! We’re about to spill the beans on the five best substitutes for blood oranges that’ll keep your kitchen creations on track.

Each of these alternatives brings its own unique twist to your recipes, ensuring your dishes are anything but ordinary.

Ready to find your next go-to ingredient?

Keep reading to discover the perfect swap for your cooking endeavors!

The 5 Best Substitutes for Blood Oranges

If you’ve been searching for a suitable substitute for blood oranges, you may be feeling somewhat perplexed.

Blood oranges have a unique flavor that can’t easily be replicated by other fruits or juices.

Luckily, there are some options that may fit the bill as a suitable replacement for your recipe.

Here are five of the best substitutes for blood oranges:

1 – Cara Cara Oranges

Cara Cara oranges are unique citrus fruits due to their ruby red flesh and intense sweetness.

Its citrusy aroma and ambrosial taste create an experience that sets it apart from ordinary oranges.

Its flesh is much juicier compared to regular Navel oranges but also has a slight tartness that makes for a well-rounded flavor.

As a result, Cara Caras makes excellent ingredients for cocktails in place of standard blood oranges.

Their sweetness is perfect for bringing balance to the herbal flavors of popular spirits such as gin or vodka, so the next time you’re looking for something special to add to your beverages, reach out for some Cara Cara oranges.

2 – Valencia Oranges

Valencia oranges are a citrus fruit that is truly impressive in its versatility.

Sweet yet tangy, these oranges are great for eating raw due to their fragrant aroma and dense flesh.

Increasingly popular, they make a great addition to various recipes such as salads, fish dishes, and cocktails.

What makes them so suitable for the last category is that they can be easily substituted for blood oranges in drinks since the flavor of Valencias is similar.

Whether you’re looking to dress up your next mojito or cosmopolitan, Valencia oranges will bring a wonderful zestiness to the cocktail without overpowering other ingredients.

3 – Grapefruit Juice

Have you ever tried grapefruit juice? If not, now’s your chance to be enlightened.

This juicy citrus drink has been gaining popularity lately, and for a good reason.

Its tart sweetness is an absolutely delightful flavor that tantalizes the tastebuds.

Its texture can range from slightly grainy to velvety smooth, which makes each glass of juice a special treat.

And if you’re looking to spice up your mixed drinks, you can use grapefruit juice as a substitute for blood oranges.

Just adjust the amount according to your own preferences and enjoy a unique twist on classic cocktails.

4 – Pink Grapefruit

Pink grapefruit is a bright, cheerful citrus fruit that is not only packed with vitamin C but also adds a unique flavor to cooking and cocktails.

Just one pink grapefruit provides more than half of an adult’s daily vitamin C needs, making it an incredibly healthy addition to any diet.

Its taste varies from tart and slightly bitter to sweet and juicy – the perfect combination of sour and tart at the same time.

The redder the ruby-pink color, the juicier and sweeter it will be, thanks to its carotenoid content.

Pink grapefruits are a great way to spice up cocktails like Margaritas or even Devil’s punch – simply substitute blood oranges with them.

And don’t forget about segmenting it for salads or adding it to marinades for fish or lamb.

5 – Navel Oranges

Navel oranges are a classic citrus fruit with a bright, sweet flavor and refreshing taste.

Favored for their ease of peeling, navel oranges have an almost perfect balance of sweetness and acidity.

The interior pulp is juicy, and the flesh is firm, with an easily segmented texture that adds to the pleasure of eating them.

This beloved type of orange adds great visual appeal to salads, desserts, and other dishes, as well as cocktails or mocktails.

For example, substituting navel oranges in place of blood oranges in drinks yields a similar but slightly milder flavor without losing any of the tartness from its citrusy zest.

Overall, navel oranges can be used in a variety of ways for their distinct flavor, juicy texture, and nutritional value.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Blood Oranges

Can't find blood oranges for your recipe? Explore the five best substitutes that offer a similar sweet-tart flavor and vibrant color to enhance your dishes.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Cara Cara Oranges
  • Valencia Oranges
  • Grapefruit Juice
  • Pink Grapefruit
  • Navel Oranges


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword Substitutes for Blood Oranges
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating