Skip to Content

Bread Maker vs Oven: What’s the Difference?

Do you want to make your own bread but don’t know whether it’s better to use a bread maker or an oven?

You can make delicious bread either way, but there are important differences between the two.

Learn about the advantages and disadvantages of each method so you can choose which is best for you.

What is a Bread Maker?

A bread maker is an electronic kitchen appliance that automates the process of making bread from start to finish.

It kneads, rises, and bakes the dough all in one machine, eliminating the need for manual labor.

The result is fresh bread without adding artificial preservatives or ingredients that are typically found in store-bought bread.

As you can see, a bread maker does much of the work traditionally done by hand or with an oven.

It simplifies the process of making homemade bread by taking care of each step along the way.

Not only does it make your life easier, but it also ensures consistent results every time.

In summary, a bread maker is a handy kitchen gadget that automates the process of making homemade bread, resulting in fresher and healthier loaves with minimal effort on your part.

What is an Oven?

An oven is a kitchen appliance used for cooking, baking, and roasting food.

It primarily uses heating elements or gas flames to cook food evenly.

It comes in various sizes and types, including conventional, convection, and microwave ovens.

When it comes to baking bread, using an oven requires more traditional methods that involve kneading the dough by hand or with an electric mixer before placing it in a preheated oven at a specific temperature range for 20-30 minutes or more.

The type of oven used will dictate the cooking time and temperature needed to produce desirable results.

Because ovens are versatile appliances, they offer the advantage of being able to cook several dishes simultaneously at varying temperatures in different pans or trays.

Differences Between Bread Maker and Oven

Bread makers and ovens serve the same purpose, which is to bake foods, but they have several differences.

Another significant difference between bread makers and ovens is the amount of time required for baking.

Bread makers are designed to quickly bake your bread with minimal supervision needed.

It often takes only a few hours or less, while an oven requires more time as you need to preheat it before usage and monitor your food regularly during the baking process.

Lastly, maintaining hygiene is essential when preparing food.

Bread makers are easy to clean since they usually come with non-stick pans that reduced the amount of cleaning required after baking.

However, ovens tend to accumulate more dirt and grime from regular exposure to food residue, making cleaning a slightly challenging task.

Method of Baking

The method of baking depends on whether you use a bread maker or an oven.

Let’s take a look at the differences in the baking process for each appliance below:

1 – Bread Maker.

  • All-in-one machine that mixes, kneads, rises and bakes dough automatically.
  • Ideal for those who are short on time or do not want to deal with the hassle of manual preparation.
  • Bakes bread with a uniform texture using a fixed bake time and heat setting.
  • May not produce artisanal quality bread due to limited customization options.

2 – Oven.

  • Separate machine that requires manual mixing and kneading of dough before baking.
  • Allows more control over the baking process and offers greater flexibility with different types of bread and recipes.
  • Can produce varying textures based on factors such as temperature, humidity, and desired crust hardness.
  • Suitable for producing a wider range of bread styles such as sourdough or whole wheat.

As you can see from the table, both appliances have their advantages depending on your preferred method of baking.

A bread maker is convenient if you’re pressed for time or don’t want to go through the trouble of manually preparing dough, but it may not offer as much variety in terms of textures and flavors.

Ease of Use

When it comes to baking bread, there are two main options: a bread maker or an oven.

The ease of use is an important aspect to consider before choosing between the two.

When using a bread maker, the process is quite simple.

All you have to do is add your ingredients and press the right buttons.

The machine does most of the work for you, from mixing and kneading to proofing and baking.

This makes it an easy option even for beginners.

On the other hand, using an oven requires more effort and preparation.

You need to properly knead, shape and proof your dough before putting it in the oven.

Then, there’s the added task of constantly monitoring and adjusting the temperature and time as needed throughout baking.

Overall, if ease of use is your top priority then a bread maker would be your best choice as it requires minimal effort and intervention from you compared to an oven.

Control Over the Baking Process

When it comes to controlling the baking process, bread makers and ovens differ significantly.

Bread makers are equipped with specific settings that allow for precise control over the entire process from mixing to kneading to rising and finally baking.

In contrast, although ovens can be modified in many ways, they don’t have specialized features like a bread maker.

As we can see, bread makers enable complete automation of the entire baking process while ovens require manual adjustments throughout various stages of bread making.

Regarding control over the baking process, using a bread maker allows you to select several options depending on your preferences.

For example, you can choose a different crust type such as light or dark crust, choose to have your bread baked at different temperatures such as high or low heat.

With an oven, you are entirely responsible for manually adjusting all aspects of your bake – how long it takes to heat up, when to place the dough inside and when to take it out.

Although using an oven provides flexibility regarding what kind of dish you can prepare with it, from cakes to roasts apart from making bread.

Overall, both appliances offer varying levels of control during some phase of manufacture.

Bread Quality

The quality of the bread is an important aspect when it comes to deciding between a bread maker and an oven.

It is a common belief that baking bread in an oven yields better quality bread than using a bread maker, but is this always the case?

There are some advantages and disadvantages to both methods.

The bread maker offers more consistency with kneading, rising, and baking compared to baking in an oven, which can lead to uneven baking.

However, bread makers have limited space and thus can only bake small loaves.

Overall, the quality of the bread ultimately depends on personal preferences and the type of bread being baked.

For those who value consistency and convenience, a bread maker might be the way to go.

For those who are true baking enthusiasts, an oven with careful monitoring might be more fulfilling.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Using a Bread Maker

When it comes to baking bread, choosing between a bread maker and an oven can be a confusing task.

To help you decide which method suits your needs the best, let’s take a closer look at the benefits and drawbacks of using a bread maker.


  • Convenience: Bread makers are incredibly easy to use and require minimal effort. Simply add the ingredients, select the program, and wait for your fresh loaf of bread.
  • Consistency: Bread makers have precise settings that ensure consistent results every time you bake. You won’t have to worry about variations in temperature or timing as with an oven.
  • Time-saving: With a bread maker, you’ll save time on kneading, proofing and shaping dough.


  • Cost: Bread makers can be expensive compared to other kitchen appliances, meaning they might not fit into everyone’s budget.
  • Limitations: Bread makers only allow for small batches of bread at a time, making them less practical when baking large quantities for events or big families.
  • Lack of Control: Despite their precision settings, some users feel like they lack control over the bread-making process with a bread maker.

One of the most significant advantages of using a bread maker is its convenience; you don’t need any special skills or knowledge to use one.

Additionally, bread makers are equipped with precise settings that ensure consistent results every time you bake, even if you’re inexperienced at making bread from scratch.

However, there are some drawbacks too.

For example, some people feel like they lack control over the baking process when using a machine instead of cooking bread in an oven.

Additionally, bread makers are designed to handle small batches of dough at a time, limiting their practicality if you’re preparing bread for big families or events.

Despite their limitations, bread makers are still a popular option for anyone who wants to save time and effort when it comes to making fresh, homemade bread.

However, you’ll also need to consider that these machines come with a higher price tag compared to traditional methods.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Using an Oven

If you are thinking about making bread at home, you can use an oven to bake your dough.

While there are several advantages to using an oven to make bread, there are also a few drawbacks that you should be aware of.

Here are some benefits and drawbacks of using an oven for baking bread.

To help you better understand the benefits and drawbacks of using an oven, we have prepared a table for you.

It summarizes the advantages and disadvantages of using this appliance for baking bread.

One benefit of using an oven is that it has a large capacity, which means that you can bake more than one loaf at a time or other baked goods alongside your bread.

Additionally, ovens are versatile, allowing you to bake many types of loaves beyond regular sliced bread such as sourdough or rye bread.

Finally, if used correctly and with practice, ovens offer consistent results in terms of coloration and crust texture.

However, when compared with a bread maker, one common drawback associated with the use of ovens is the lack of control over temperature precision during baking.

Ovens are not designed to regulate internal temperatures instantly like contemporary machines do.

Additionally, ovens require much more time for preheating before you can start baking compared to bread makers.

Another disadvantage would be inconsistent heat distribution inside your oven which can lead to unevenly cooked loaves in certain areas which could affect overall quality.

Which Option is Better?

To determine which option is better between a bread maker and an oven, let’s take a closer look at the benefits and drawbacks of each.

  • Let’s compare the convenience of both options. While a bread maker may be more convenient since it takes care of all aspects of baking the bread, an oven allows for more versatility in terms of what can be baked. You can not only bake bread in an oven but also other baked goods like cakes, cookies, and pies.
  • Next, considering cost-effectiveness, a bread maker might seem expensive upfront but proves to be cheaper in the long run since it saves time, effort and electricity bills. On the other hand, ovens are multipurpose and could serve as practically anything from stoves to grills. They tend to be slightly more affordable compared to bread makers but expenses such as electricity bills would prove considerable over time.
  • Now, let’s think about skill level. A bread maker does not require any special skills or techniques aside from measuring ingredients accurately whereas baking with an oven requires more knowledge on temperature control and how ingredients react together during different stages of baking. If you’re looking for something easy for beginners then a bread machine is your pick.
  • Furthermore considering size preference or quantity produced while using either options solely depend on individual preferences since it comes with varying sizes to suit personal needs.


A bread maker and an oven both serve their purpose for baking bread, but which one is better? Another significant difference between these two appliances is their size.

Bread makers are typically small and compact while ovens are much larger.

If you have limited space in your kitchen or live alone, a bread maker might be the perfect choice for you.

But if you have a big family or often entertain guests at home, you might want to go with an oven as it will allow you to make bigger batches of bread at once.

Bread Maker vs Oven: What’s the Difference?

Andrew Gray
Contemplating the disparities between a bread maker and an oven? Explore our comparison to understand the distinctions in their functionalities and applications.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That
Servings 1 Serving


  • Bread Maker
  • Oven


  • Choose between a bread maker and an oven based on your preference and baking needs.
  • Follow the specific instructions provided by the manufacturer for your chosen appliance.
  • Prepare your bread dough according to your recipe, ensuring it is properly mixed and kneaded.
  • If using a bread maker, place the dough into the machine, select the appropriate program, and start the bread-making process.
  • If using an oven, preheat it to the recommended temperature and shape your dough accordingly.
  • For the bread maker, allow the machine to complete the entire baking process as per the selected program.
  • For the oven, place the shaped dough into a baking pan or directly onto a baking sheet, and bake for the recommended time and temperature.
  • Once the baking time is complete, check for doneness by tapping the bread or using a skewer to ensure it is fully cooked.
  • Remove the bread from the bread maker or oven and let it cool on a wire rack.
  • Slice and enjoy your freshly baked bread, appreciating the convenience and delicious results provided by either the bread maker or oven.
  • Experiment with different recipes and techniques to fully explore the versatility of your chosen baking method.
Keyword Bread Maker vs Oven
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating