Skip to Content

Brick Cheese vs Mozzarella: What’s the Difference?

Ever heard of Brick cheese? Yep, it’s real. And mozzarella? Every pizza’s best friend.

We’re about to deep-dive into the epic showdown between these two dairy giants.

Brick cheese, despite its construction-sounding name, is as creamy and dreamy as they come. Originating from Wisconsin, it’s got a history. Mozzarella, on the other hand, hails from Italy – the land of pasta, pizza, and cheese that pulls apart like it’s in a slow-mo food commercial.

We’ve all had that moment in a grocery aisle, staring at an array of cheeses, wondering what in the world sets them apart.

Here, we’ll spill the beans – or the curd, to be more cheese-accurate.

What is Brick Cheese?

Brick cheese is a type of cheese that originates from the United States and is popular in the Midwest region.

This versatile cheese has a mildly spicy taste and a crumbly texture, which makes it ideal for melting and grilling.

It is made using cow’s milk, and its production process involves shaping the curd into a brick-like form hence its name.

The history of Brick Cheese is interesting.

The original production process involved using traditional methods where the curd was pressed into rectangular shapes to fit the bottom of shipping crates, lined with parchment paper.

Later on, cheesemakers began wrapping them in foil- hence becoming packed in bricks.

What is Mozzarella?

Mozzarella is a popular Italian cheese made from the milk of water buffalos.

It has a milky and delicate flavor with a soft and stretchy texture.

The cheese is commonly used in dishes such as pizza, lasagna, and caprese salad.

Its popularity has resulted in various versions of mozzarella like whole milk, partially skimmed and skimmed milk varieties.

The production process for Mozzarella is quite distinctive as it undergoes stretching.

This method releases whey protein which results in the cheese’s unique texture.

Once stretched, it is shaped into round balls or blocks and then stored in brine to preserve its freshness.

The cheese can be enjoyed either fresh or aged depending on personal preference.

One unique aspect of Mozzarella cheese is that it can be produced from different types of milk like sheep, goat or cow’s milk, which provides different textures & flavours to the product while maintaining its elasticity during preparation.

Overall, Mozzarella is an essential ingredient for any dish that requires melted or stringy cheese.

So, whether you’re a foodie or not try variation based on your preferences.

Differences Between Brick Cheese and Mozzarella

Brick cheese and Mozzarella have distinct textures, flavors, and uses.

Brick cheese, with its strong flavor and semi-soft texture, is a great choice for pizzas and sandwiches, while Mozzarella’s mild taste and high moisture content make it perfect for salads and melting on top of dishes.

Another difference is in the production process; Brick cheese is ripened for at least two months, while Mozzarella is not aged for more than a few weeks.

These variations make the two types of cheeses unique in their own way.

1 – Origin and History

The tale of Brick Cheese goes back to the early 19th century, where it was first produced in Wisconsin.

The city of Colby is thought to be its place of birth, and legend has it that a cheese maker by the name of John Jossi, invented the cheese as a way to incorporate extra curds left over from his everyday production into a new recipe.

With Mozzarella, however, its history goes way back to ancient Italy.

Fractions on this delicacy’s origin can be traced back to Greek mythology.

Nonetheless, evidence suggests that an Italian man named Raffaele Esposito created the modern iteration for King Umberto I and Queen Margherita during the 19th century.

When it comes down to differentiating Brick Cheese and Mozzarella, there are several factors to consider.

Brick Cheese is zesty and more robust compared to soft-textured Mozzarella used in mainly pasta dishes.

Another notable difference between these cheeses is their ageing process; typically, Brick Cheese ages longer than Mozzarella as it gains more flavour with time.

However, both types are widely popular across many cuisines worldwide and bring unique flavours to every dish they grace upon.

In comparison with each other, Brick Cheese vs Mozzarella brings two distinct idiosyncrasies worth tasting.

While meats prefer the hardiness of Brick Cheese because it maintains its shape while producing an intense flavour profile upon melting; softer foods like pizzas or salads would opt for the smoothness of mozzarella that also adds depth with less intensity.

2 – Cheese-making Process

The process of making cheese involves several steps, including fermentation, coagulation, and separation of curd from the whey.

The milk used for brick cheese is heated and stirred before adding cultures to develop flavor.

The mixture is then curdled using rennet and cut into cubes.

The curds are further heated and placed in molds for pressing.

In contrast, Mozzarella is made by heating milk until it forms a curd which is then stretched in hot water before being shaped into balls or logs.

This stretching process gives mozzarella its unique texture and stretchiness.

It’s worth noting that Brick cheese typically has a higher fat content than mozzarella due to the addition of cream to make it more favorable for aging and slicing.

Additionally, the different processes used in making these cheeses can result in different flavors and textures that cater to different preferences.

3 – Texture and Melting Properties

The Texture and Melting Properties of Brick Cheese and Mozzarella are two factors that differentiate them.

Brick cheese has a crumbly and dense texture, while Mozzarella has a springy and elastic one.

Brick cheese melts easily but is less stretchy than Mozzarella.

In contrast, Mozzarella is known for its smooth melting properties as it can be pulled into long strings without breaking apart.

4 – Flavor and Aroma

The sensory characteristics of Brick Cheese and Mozzarella cheese differ in many ways.

While Brick cheese has a stronger aroma that emanates from its bacterial community, Mozzarella has a milder scent.

The taste of Brick Cheese is nuttier and tangier compared to the mild flavor of Mozzarella.

Additionally, Brick cheese tends to overpower other flavors, while Mozzarella blends well with other foods without overshadowing them.

5 – Culinary Uses and Pairings

The culinary versatility of both brick cheese and mozzarella is immense, catering to various dishes and pairings.

From pizzas to sandwiches, mozzarella is a popular choice due to its mild and creamy texture.

On the other hand, brick cheese’s nutty and savory notes make it perfect for mac n’ cheese or burgers.

When it comes to pairing, mozzarella compliments light-bodied white wines while brick cheese goes well with full-bodied reds.

Every plate has a personality and choosing between brick cheese or mozzarella can enhance that character.

Similarities Between Brick Cheese and Mozzarella

Brick cheese and Mozzarella share several similarities in their texture, appearance, and use.

Both have a smooth texture and can be melted easily.

They are commonly used on pizza, in sandwiches, and as a topping or filling for various dishes.

Brick Cheese and Mozzarella have mild flavors that complement the taste of other ingredients.

In terms of nutritional value, both cheeses offer similar protein content per ounce.

However, there are some distinct differences between them as well.

One significant variation is the production process; Mozzarella is stretched while it’s still hot whereas Brick cheese settles under its weight during the aging process.

This difference gives Brick cheese a stronger flavor than Mozzarella.

Brick cheese also has a firmer and denser texture than Mozzarella.

As a result, Brick cheese may not work well on pizzas with thin crusts because it’s heavier than Mozzarella.

Although both these cheeses go well in dishes that call for melting cheese, they do have unique characteristics that may make one more suitable than the other based on individual preferences and cooking styles.

Understanding these differences allows for better ingredient selection to achieve the desired effect in one’s cuisine without compromising its quality or taste.

Where to Buy Brick Cheese and Mozzarella?

The availability of Brick Cheese and Mozzarella can vary by location and store.

These cheeses can be found in specialty cheese shops, grocery stores, and even online markets.

Additionally, some stores may carry both types of cheese, while others may only have one or the other.

It’s important to check with your local retailers or online markets for availability and pricing before making a purchase.

When considering where to buy Brick Cheese or Mozzarella, it’s also important to note the freshness of the cheese.

Some stores may sell pre-packaged cheese that has been sitting on the shelf for a while, while others may offer freshly made options.

Checking the expiration date or asking about freshness can ensure you’re purchasing high-quality cheese.

Furthermore, some regions or countries may specialize in producing certain types of cheese.

For example, Wisconsin is known for its production of Brick Cheese, while Italy is famous for its Mozzarella di Bufala.

If you’re looking for authentic versions of these cheeses, it may be worth seeking out specialty shops that focus on imported goods.

In summary, finding where to buy Brick Cheese and Mozzarella will depend on your location and preferred method of purchase.

Specialty cheese shops, grocery stores, and online markets are all potential options to consider when seeking out these delicious cheeses.


After a detailed analysis of the differences between brick cheese and mozzarella, it is clear that both cheeses offer unique features that cater to different palate preferences.

One important aspect to note is that both cheeses have distinct characteristics that can greatly impact the overall taste of a dish.

While brick cheese has a tangy and acidic taste due to its fermentation process, mozzarella has a subtle sweetness which comes from pasteurized milk.

Moreover, brick cheese has a crumbly texture which melts well while cooking, while mozzarella has a stretchy texture that makes it ideal for dishes like lasagna or caprese salad.

Brick Cheese vs Mozzarella: What’s the Difference?

Andrew Gray
Embark on a cheese-tasting adventure as you unravel the disparities between Brick Cheese and Mozzarella. Explore how these two cheeses, with their distinct textures and flavor profiles, contribute uniquely to various culinary creations, from pizzas to sandwiches.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That


  • Brick Cheese
  • Mozzarella


  • Choose between brick cheese and mozzarella based on your preference and the desired flavor and texture for your dish.
  • Incorporate the selected cheese into your recipe, following the recommended quantity or to suit your taste.
  • Ensure the cheese is evenly distributed throughout the dish, whether by grating, slicing, or melting it.
  • Cook or bake the dish according to the recipe instructions, allowing the cheese to melt and enhance the flavors.
  • Serve and enjoy the delightful taste and creamy texture imparted by either brick cheese or mozzarella.
  • Experiment with different recipes and dishes to explore the versatility of each cheese and discover your favorite uses for them.
Keyword Brick Cheese vs Mozzarella
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating