Skip to Content

The 5 Best Substitutes for Castelvetrano Olives

Did you know that Castelvetrano Olives are small, round, mild, and buttery-tasting olives?

They feature a unique flavor profile totally different from common green or black olives.

If you’re looking for new culinary experiences, Castelvetrano Olives can be a great option to spruce up your daily cooking routine.

But what if they aren’t available in the store or you run out of them? In that case, we recommend substituting this delightful olive with other similar ingredients to get the same authentic olive experience at home.

In this article, we will explore how to cook with Castelvetrano Olives as well as list the top 5 substitutes for this ingredient.

Let’s get started.

What’s Castelvetrano Olive?

Castelvetrano olives are an Italian variety of olives known for their bright color and nutty flavor.

These spectacular olives come from the area around Castelvetrano, Sicily, and have been grown in this region as far back as Ancient Rome.

In appearance, Castelvetrano olives are large and deep green in color with a buttery texture that melts in your mouth.

They offer a slight tartness with a hint of sweetness and a balanced combination of fruitiness and saltiness.

Traditionally these olives were used as martini garnishes but can also be added to salads or eaten as they are as a delicious snack.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Castelvetrano Olives

If you are looking for a substitute for Castelvetrano olives, there are a few options available.

Here is a list of the five best substitutes for Castelvetrano olives:

1 – Picholine Olives

Picholine olives are a variety that is beloved for their fragrant and slightly tart flavor.

They have a delicate texture, making them perfect as a snack or as an addition to many dishes.

They are also the perfect substitute for the more costly Castelvetrano olives – with their fleshy texture and intense buttery flavor, Picholine olives make an excellent alternative to the expensive favorites.

Craving those bright green gems? Reach for some Picholine olives – they’re sure to satisfy.

2 – Cerignola Olives

Cerignola olives are among the most popular Italian green table olives.

These large, round olives have a mild flavor and meaty texture that is distinctive without being overpowering.

These olives make a great snack on their own, plus they can be used to enhance dishes like salads or pasta.

For cooks looking for a substitute for Castelvetrano olives, Cerignola olives will do the trick: their unique flavor will stand up to robust flavors, and the larger size of Cerignola makes them an impressive feature on any plate.

3 – Manzilla Olives

Manzanilla olives, a type of mixed U.S. olive, have come to the limelight in recent years and offer an exciting alternative to traditional Castelvetrano olives.

With their distinctive flavor profile and bright popping color, Manzanilla olives are quickly becoming a staple in pantries across the country.

They have a slightly tart taste with the perfect hint of bitterness that works well with salads, antipasti platters, or even as a topping for sandwiches.

The texture is slightly chewier than Castelvetrano olives.

However, they have a uniquely enjoyable crunch.

As an olive enthusiast who loves trying different varieties, I highly recommend Manzanilla Olives as a great substitute for Castelvetrano in your favorite dishes.

4 – Kalamata Olives

Kalamata olives are a famous Greek food popular in Europe and the Middle East.

Often used as part of a salad, kalamata olives have a unique flavor that is both salty and intense.

They have a dense and meaty texture, making them an ideal topping or addition to dishes.

For those looking to substitute Castelvetrano olives in their recipes, Kalamata olives make an excellent substitution due to their similar color and shape.

However, they offer a stronger flavor that is more assertive and salty than many other types of green olives.

5 – Liguria Olives

Liguria Olives are a flavorful and colorful addition to any dish.

These mild, subtly salty olives have a creamy texture that can melt in your mouth – they’re incredibly delicious.

If you wish to substitute Castelvetrano olives for Liguria olives, it’s easy to do so, as the flavor is quite similar.

Liguria olives are often brighter in appearance and a bit milder in flavor but bring the same beautiful green hue to any olive dish.

These olives work great with everything from salads to sandwiches and pasta recipes, always bringing richness and complexity to taste.


In the end, there are several excellent substitutes for Castelvetrano olives that offer their own unique flavor and texture.

Whether you choose Picholine, Cerignola, Manzanilla, Kalamata or Liguria olives, your dish will still be as delicious and flavorful as ever – just with a new spin.

So go ahead and experiment – the possibilities are endless.

Yield: 1 Serving

The 5 Best Substitutes for Castelvetrano Olives

The 5 Best Substitutes for Castelvetrano Olives
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes


  • Picholine Olives
  • Cerignola Olives
  • Manzilla Olives
  • Kalamata Olives
  • Liguria Olives


  1. Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  2. Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Skip to Recipe