Skip to Content

The 5 Best Dressings for Potato Salad

Potato salad is a classic summer dish that can bring life to any outdoor gathering.

But with the wide variety of dressings and ingredients available, it can be hard to decide which type of dressing to use for a delicious, memorable potato salad.

This article will dive into the 5 best dressings you should consider when making your own potato salad so you can create a flavor-packed recipe that everyone will love.

We’ll also explain what to look for in each dressing and how to achieve the perfect balance of flavors.

Get ready to dine on the perfect potato salad – questions welcome.

Why Dressings are Important for Potato Salad?

Potato salad is an incredibly versatile dish that can be served as either a side or main course.

The right dressing can add flavor and texture to potato salads and make them more enjoyable for everyone.

Depending on the ingredients and flavors you use, dressings can also provide a unique twist to your potato salad recipes.

Knowing what type of dressing to choose, how much to use, and in what order will help you create perfectly flavored dishes every time.

Depending on the ingredients used, dressings can enhance the overall appearance and flavor of potato salads.

Most people prefer creamy dressings for their potato salad because they give it an added sweetness that combines perfectly with other flavors like onion, garlic, mayonnaise, and pickles.

Creamy dressings like ranch-style dressings are also great for binding ingredients together so that your potatoes don’t stay dry or lumpy after they’ve been cooked.

Other popular types of dressing include vinaigrettes and various types of mayo-based ones.

Vinaigrette dressings are usually lighter on their own but have distinct tangy notes when combined with your other ingredients like onions or peppers if desired.

Mayonnaise-based dressings are usually thicker than vinaigrettes and add a richer flavor profile to your recipe thanks to its high fat content.

While they tend to overpower lighter flavors like herbs or lemon juice, these ultra-creamy options impart a certain polish to the dish that’s hard not to love.

Modern cooks have experimented with all sorts of exotic additions when it comes to dressing potato salads, but just remember – keep it simple.

By choosing the right type of dressing for your recipe along with just enough seasoning (a pinch of salt can be enough), you’ll be able guarantee every delicious bite after everyone at the table has had their fill.

Criteria for Choosing the Best Dressings

While there are endless variations and dressings available, we’ve narrowed down five of the most important criteria for selecting the best dressings for your potato salad.

Consider each factor when choosing a dressing for your potato salad to ensure that it truly is the best.

  • Flavor: Choose a dressing with flavors that complement the other ingredients in the potato salad. Examples of flavor pairings include adding dill with cucumber, apple cider vinegar with red onion, and lemon with herbs.
  • Taste: Look for dressings that will balance out the saltiness of potatoes and maximize flavor potential. Some dressings are tangier while others are sweeter, so consider what will work best in terms of taste preferences when selecting a dressing.
  • Texture: Consider how a dressing will affect texture — do you want crunchy pieces or creamy swirls? Greek yogurt dressings add creaminess while vinaigrette-style dressings provide a lighter option with minimal mess and clean-up time.
  • Creaminess: Potatoes tend to absorb more liquid than other vegetables, so opt for thicker or creamier dressings if you prefer thick coating on your potatoes rather than thin soup-like consistency. Salads dressed in mayonnaise or creamy yogurt tend to have this effect as opposed to oil based vinaigrettes which often remain thin upon absorbing moisture from other ingredients.
  • Health Benefits: Many people opt for more healthful choice when deciding on their dressing ingredientsyogurt adds protein, olive oil contains healthy fat alternatives, etc). Consider what nutrition benefits would be gained by choosing one particular dressing over another – look up nutritional facts to compare different options and its effect on flavor profiles as well as calorie counts if needed.

The 5 Best Dressings for Potato Salad

Potato salads can be a great accompaniment to any meal or summer gathering.

However, the wrong dressing can leave you with a soggy and unappetizing dish.

Therefore, it is important to choose the right dressing in order to create a delicious and flavorful potato salad.

Here is a list of five dressings to help you make the perfect potato salad:

1. Classic Mustard Dressing

This classic dressing for potato salad is a great option if you’re looking to keep things simple.

It’s made with a combination of smooth Dijon mustard, mayonnaise, vinegar, minced onion, and sugar.

This combination creates a unique balance of sweetness, tanginess and kick.

The vinegar helps to lighten up the dish and balances out the flavor of the mayo and mustard.

Add some seasoning such as salt and pepper to bring out the flavors even further.

While this dressing is typically used in its original form, you can experiment by adding a bit of your favorite herbs or spices for more complexity.

2. Ranch Dressing

Ranch dressing is a staple for most salads and is excellent for potato salad.

To make it, mix together sour cream, mayonnaise, fresh herbs, and other flavorings.

You can also buy pre-made ranch dressing if you’re pressed for time.

The combination of these creamy ingredients will make your potato salad taste even better.

For a lighter version, you could try substituting plain Greek yogurt instead of the mayonnaise and sour cream.

For an extra boost of flavor add in some diced scallions, bacon bits or crumbled feta cheese before serving your potato salad with ranch dressing.

3. Bacon Blue Cheese Dressing

This dressing adds an extra kick of flavor to your potato salad that will have everyone asking for the recipe.

The combination of blue cheese and bacon gives the dressing an intense and rich flavor that is perfect for any kind of potato salad.

You can adjust the proportion of blue cheese and bacon to your preference and it’s pretty simple to make, even with minimal ingredients.

Start off by frying some cubes of bacon until they are crispy, then set them aside on a plate lined with paper towels.

Now in a blender (or food processor), add some mayonnaise, crumbled blue cheese, sour cream, garlic powder, pepper, white vinegar, and dill.

Whiz up all these ingredients until they are well blended together – you don’t want any solids left in the mix.

Once everything is blended together well and creamy, pour into a bowl and whisk in some olive oil or vegetable oil until you achieve your desired consistency.

Finally stir in the crumbled bacon pieces into the mix until evenly distributed throughout.

This Bacon Blue Cheese Dressing can be served right away or stored for later use.

4. Lemon Herb Dressing

This fresh and tangy dressing adds a flavor burst to any potato salad with its citrus zing of lemon and herbs.

To make this lemony delight, mix together 2 tablespoons each of freshly squeezed lemon juice, white wine vinegar and extra virgin olive oil in a small bowl or jar.

Then add 1 teaspoon each of freshly minced garlic and dijon mustard, along with a pinch of both sea salt and freshly cracked black pepper.

For the herbs, use 1 tablespoon of finely chopped, fresh dill and 1 tablespoon of finely chopped parsley to give your dressing an added kick.

Whisk everything together until it’s completely blended.

This will make enough for one large potato salad or two small servings.

5. Creamy Dill Dressing

Creamy Dill Dressing is a cool and creamy dressing for potato salad that works perfectly during the warmer months.

The addition of dill enhances the flavor of the dressing, making it perfect for potato salads with subtle flavors like boiled potatoes, corn and peas.

This dressing can be made with sour cream or Greek yogurt and will keep in the refrigerator for up to five days.

Try mixing this Creamy Dill Dressing with your favorite ingredients to make a delicious summertime potato salad.


Potato salads can be a great addition to any meal, but their success depends on getting the ingredients and dressings right.

While everyone has their own personal favorite, there are five basic dressings that work particularly well with potato salads.

In conclusion, all five dressings discussed are excellent choices when creating potato salads that will please family and friends alike.

It ultimately comes down to one’s individual preferences as far as ingredients and flavor combinations go.

However, keep in mind that mayo-based dressing tends to last longer while lighter dressings should be served within 2 hours at room temperature or stored in cold temperatures if possible.

Ultimately though these five options are some of the best dressings out there when it comes time to make potato salad – enjoy.

The 5 Best Dressings for Potato Salad

Elevate your potato salad to new levels of deliciousness with the perfect dressing! Explore our curated selection of the 5 best dressings guaranteed to enhance the flavors and creamy texture of your potato salad.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course Side Dishes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Classic Mustard Dressing
  • Ranch Dressing
  • Bacon Blue Cheese Dressing
  • Lemon Herb Dressing
  • Creamy Dill Dressing


  • Choose your favorite dressing from the comprehensive selection provided in this article.
  • Gather all of the essential ingredients required for the recipe.
  • Prepare a delectable salad with your selected dressing in under 30 minutes, following the provided instructions.
Keyword Dressings for Potato Salad
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating