Skip to Content

Citrus Delights: 5 BEST Substitutes for Fiori Di Sicilia

Fiori Di Sicilia is the secret zing in your grandma’s cookies that had you sneaking into the kitchen at midnight.

It’s like capturing sunshine and citrus groves in a bottle, then pouring that magic into your baking.

Stumbled upon an empty Fiori Di Sicilia bottle while your mixer’s going? No sweat!

Finding a substitute might seem like trying to replace your favorite quirky character in a sitcom – impossible without losing some laughs.

Yet, here I am, your kitchen partner in crime, ready to spill the beans on five game-changing swaps.

These contenders are ready to step into the ring and bring their own punchline to your recipes.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Fiori Di Sicilia

If you’ve been looking for the perfect substitution for Fiori Di Sicilia, we think you’ll be pleased with these five options.

1 – Orange Extract

Orange extract is a concentrated powder made from the orange peel that adds an intense, rich flavor to any recipe.

Its sweet yet zesty aroma adds depth and complexity to baked desserts, beverages, sauces, and more.

The orange extract has a slightly grainy texture and a hint of bitterness due to its high citrus content, but it can be balanced out with the addition of sugar or condensed milk.

For those looking for an alternative to Fiori Di Sicilia – an Italian flavoring – orange extract can act as a reasonable substitute.

The distinctive aroma will perfectly complement rich desserts like Tiramisu while also adding a distinguished citrus flavor that’s even deeper than what Fiori Di Sicilia offers.

2 – Vanilla Extract

Vanilla extract has been a long-standing pantry staple, used to add rich flavor and aroma to sweets and baked goods.

Made by soaking vanilla beans in a combination of alcohol and water, it’s easy to measure out and use in recipes.

The taste is sweet but with a hint of bitterness towards the end, while its texture is still liquidy yet subtly thick when drizzled on a spoon.

When using the vanilla extract for baking purposes, it can be substituted for Fiori Di Sicilia, which contains notes of orange blossom.

Either way, you’ll get that truly delightful flavor that takes your desserts to the next level.

3 – Millefiori Extract

Millefiori Extract is an incredibly unique product combining the sweet citrusy taste of oranges with a hint of vanilla and spices.

Millefiori has a rich and complex flavor that sets it apart from other extracts.

It is slightly thicker than the traditional vanilla extract and has a creamy, almost buttery texture.

This extract gives pastries, bread, and cakes an added layer of flavor that can bring any dish to life.

Though similar to Fiori Di Sicilia, Millefiori Extract includes more subtle floral notes of orange blossom for milder flavors that stand out on their own or are used as a fragrant substitution for Fiori Di Sicilia in certain recipes.

4 – Lemon Extract

Lemon extract is a common flavoring in baking.

Its sweet-tart flavor adds brightness to cakes and other treats, as well as subtle citrus notes.

This extract also provides a pleasant texture in addition to its distinctive taste.

Lemon extract is often made with vegetable glycerin, which creates a flavor that can be described as light and intensely lemony, without any of the bitterness of the zest or juice of a lemon.

If you need an alternative to Fiori Di Sicilia—an Italian-style lemon extract used frequently in Neapolitan desserts—lemon extract can be used instead.

Just remember that Fiori Di Sicilia has additional ingredients beyond lemon extract, and it won’t provide quite the same flavor profile.

5 – Orange Blossom Water

Orange blossom water is a fragrant distillation of the essential oils from orange blossoms.

It has a light, subtle scent and a slightly citrus flavor.

Used in baking, it adds a delightful flavor to cakes, ice creams, custards, and jams; it is sometimes added to rice dishes to enhance the flavor or mixed into drinks such as mint lemonade for an extra special taste.

Orange blossom water has a syrupy texture and can be used as a substitute for Fiori di Sicilia extract in baking recipes that call for it.

To replace Fiori di Sicilia with orange blossom water, use a 1:1 ratio – one tablespoon of Fiori di Sicilia equals one tablespoon of orange blossom water – dilute it with water if you prefer a milder flavor.

Enjoy experimenting with this unique ingredient.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Fiori Di Sicilia

Fiori di Sicilia adds a unique citrus and vanilla flavor to baked goods, but if you're out, try these five substitutes for a similarly delightful taste in your recipes.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Orange Extract
  • Vanilla Extract
  • Millefiori Extract
  • Lemon Extract
  • Orange Blossom Water


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword Substitutes for Fiori Di Sicilia
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating