Skip to Content

Dessert Delights: 5 BEST Substitutes for Ice Cream

Oh boy, have you ever stood in front of the freezer, eyeing that ice cream tub like it’s the last one on Earth, yet your brain’s going, “Maybe not today”? I get it.

Sometimes, we all want to switch things up or look for something a tad healthier or just different.

Lucky for you, I’ve scoured the land of frozen treats and beyond to bring you the top five knock-your-socks-off substitutes for ice cream.

Trust me, these alternatives are so good, you might just forget about the classic pint.

Ready to give your taste buds a thrill without the chill? Let’s dive in!

The 5 Best Substitutes for Ice Cream

If you’re looking for a healthier alternative to ice cream, then you’ve come to the right place.

Whether you’re looking to cut down on added sugars or just want a dairy-free option, there are plenty of delicious substitutes that will satisfy your craving without all the guilt.

Here are five of the top alternatives to traditional ice cream that you can enjoy any time of the year:

1 – Frozen Yogurt

Frozen yogurt is a delicious treat that is made by combining milk, sugar, yogurt culture, and stabilizers.

While it contains fewer calories than traditional ice cream, it has a similar creamy texture and slightly tart flavor that makes it just as enjoyable to eat.

Although frozen yogurt is often mixed with various toppings, including fresh fruit and nuts, it can also be replaced with ice cream in many recipes.

For example, try using frozen yogurt instead of ice cream when making a homemade milkshake or smoothie – you’ll get the same flavor without adding extra calories.

2 – Greek Yogurt Popsicles

Cool down this summer with Greek Yogurt Popsicles.

For a healthier alternative to your favorite ice creams, grab some Greek yogurt and create delicious fruit-based popsicles.

Combining different fruits creates an exciting variety of colors and tastes ready to be mixed, like mango, passionfruit, coconut, and more.

These chilling alternatives offer the same sweet flavors of ice cream with a distinctly creamy texture.

As an even healthier option, they can easily be substituted for cream in every recipe allowing you to enjoy all the same classic desserts without as much guilt.

Beat the heat and try out Greek Yogurt Popsicles for a lighter summer refreshment.

3 – Banana Ice Cream

Bananas are a delicious and healthy snack that can also be blended and frozen to make a delicious vegan substitute for ice cream.

Banana ice cream, also known as ‘nice’ cream, has become an increasingly popular dessert choice among those looking to reduce their sugar and dairy intake but still enjoy something sweet.

The texture is incredibly smooth and creamy, similar to more traditional ice cream options.

There’s also tons of room for creativity when it comes to adding flavors, from caramel swirls to fresh berries.

To make it, simply peel overripe bananas, cut them into slices, freeze overnight in an airtight container, blend until creamy, and enjoy as is or add whatever toppings you prefer.

4 – Chia Pudding

Chia pudding makes a delicious and healthy treat that satisfies any sweet tooth.

Made from chia seeds and your favorite dairy or plant-based milk, it serves as a satisfying breakfast option or a nutritious snack to get you through the day.

Chia pudding has a light and creamy texture with a slightly nutty flavor that nicely complements the sweetness of your chosen liquid base.

You can also make chia pudding with added flavors such as honey, almond extract, coconut flakes, cacao nibs, and more.

Best of all, it is an excellent substitute for ice cream – when combined with fresh fruits like berries or banana slices, chia pudding makes an amazing frozen dessert without the guilt.

5 – Protein Ice Cream

Do you love ice cream but not the sugar and fat it has? Protein ice cream can be a healthier alternative that still satisfies your sweet tooth.

It’s made from whey protein, which is an excellent source of essential amino acids, making it a nutritious way to end a workout or enjoy it as a snack.

Since it contains much less sugar than regular ice cream, it ends up having fewer calories overall.

Protein ice cream is also thicker and fluffier in texture because of the proteins and stabilizers present within the ingredients.

As a bonus, many brands enhance their creations by adding natural flavoring extracts like vanilla bean or cocoa powder, creating a truly delicious yet guilt-free treat.

Best of all, you can easily make your own version of this creamy goodness right at home.

Try blending banana and almond milk with both protein powder and non-dairy yogurt for a healthy substitution for ice cream.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Ice Cream

Craving something creamy but out of ice cream? Fear not! We've compiled a list of the 5 best substitutes that will satisfy your sweet tooth just like the real deal.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Frozen Yogurt
  • Greek Yogurt Popsicles
  • Banana Ice Cream
  • Chia Pudding
  • Protein Ice Cream


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword Substitutes for Ice Cream
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating