Skip to Content

Spice It Up: 5 BEST Substitutes for Mulato Chile

Hey there, spicy food aficionados! Ever hit a recipe roadblock thanks to a missing Mulato chile?

It’s a curveball for sure. These dark, rich peppers add a unique punch to dishes that’s hard to beat.

No sweat, though. We’ve scoured kitchens and cookbooks to bring you the top swaps that keep your meals fiery and flavorful.

Ready to discover the secret stand-ins that turn “Uh-oh” into “Oh, yes”?

Keep reading, because we’re about to spice up your cooking game like never before.

The 5 BEST Substitutes for Mulato Chiles

If you are looking for a flavorful and versatile pepper to add to your dish, then mulato chiles might be a perfect choice.

These peppers have a mild heat level and provide a smokey, earthy flavor that is both sweet and savory.

Unfortunately, these peppers can be hard to find in some areas.

Luckily, there are several great substitutes that can bring a similar flavor and heat level to your dish.

1 – Ancho Chiles

Ancho chiles are one of the most common peppers used in Mexican cuisine and beyond.

Prized for their unique flavor and versatile applications, these dried chiles are intense and smoky to the taste, giving deeply-flavored dishes a dynamic punch.

Not roasted or deseeded, the peppers have an incredibly chewy yet slightly leathery texture when eaten.

Ancho chiles can be used to make sauces, soups, stews, moles, and much more–simply soak them in hot water before grinding them up into a paste or throwing them directly into your cooking.

If you need a substitute for Mulato chiles in a recipe, anchos can serve as an interchangeable component.

2 – Pasilla Chiles

Pasilla chiles are one of the most popular and widely used chili peppers in Mexican cuisine.

Long, narrow, and dark in color, these pungent chiles have a bold yet slightly sweet flavor.

Pasillas have a smoky flavor compared to other mild to medium-hot chilies that are more intense when dried.

When dried, the chili takes on a deep raisin-like taste with some robust smokiness.

For recipes that call for Mulato chiles, Pasilla can easily be substituted as its flavor comes very close without overwhelming heat.

To cook it, simply add them directly to tacos, salads, or any dish you like – after deseeding – or roast them first over open flames before crushing or grinding them into powder form to create amazing sauces.

3 – Guajillo Chiles

Guajillo chiles are a powerhouse of flavor that is underrated in Mexican cuisine.

Dark red and somewhat wrinkled, they carry an earthy flavor with a sweet, mild heat, perfect for a satisfying zing without overwhelming spice.

Despite their smoky subtlety, they pack quite the punch when it comes to adding depth to soups and sauces.

To unlock their full potential, make sure you toast them first—this will bring out their rich and complex flavor.

For dishes that call for mulato chiles, guajillo can easily be substituted; both have similar heat levels, but guajillo tends to be tarter than slightly sweet mulatos.

Enjoy the beautiful balance provided by these chiles in Mexican dishes that are sure to please.

4 – New Mexico Chiles

New Mexico Chiles are a highly sought-after variety of chiles that are widely used for many Mexican dishes.

Harvested in late summer, these chiles range from mild to medium in heat and lend an unmistakable flavor to all the dishes they grace.

Bright and earthy, New Mexico Chiles have a dense texture that pairs exceptionally well with slow-cooked meats and stews.

To bring out the best of their flavors, roast them over an open flame until lightly charred, then remove the charred skin and add directly to your dishes.

If you’re looking for a substitute for Mulato Chiles, New Mexico Chiles would make a great option as they bear a similar flavor profile but with higher heat levels.

5 – Chipotle Chiles

Chipotle chiles are a unique ingredient that brings a deep smokiness and full-bodied flavor to all kinds of dishes.

These delicious, dried jalapeños are native to Mexico, milder than Serrano chiles yet still retain their heat.

They have a more crunchy texture compared to other dried chiles and offer an earthy, smoky-sweet flavor with a bit of a spicy kick.

Chipotles can be used both in fresh or dried form, and when cooked together, the complex flavors meld together perfectly.

To make use of chipotle, try adding it to your favorite salsa recipe or adding it to soup or stews for depth and complexity of flavor.

If you’re looking for a substitute for Mulato chiles, Chipotles are the perfect match since they deliver a similar smokiness and richness in flavor but with less intense heat than the Mulatos.

The 5 BEST Substitutes for Mulato Chiles

Out of mulato chiles? Don't worry! Explore our guide featuring the five best substitutes that will add depth and complexity to your Mexican-inspired recipes.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Ancho Chiles
  • Pasilla Chiles
  • Guajillo Chiles
  • New Mexico Chiles
  • Chipotle Chiles


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword Substitutes for Mulato Chiles
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating