Skip to Content

Pimento Seeds vs Allspice: What’s the Difference?

Pimento seeds and allspice often get mixed up in the kitchen. We’re here to clear the air.

Pimentos pack a punch in flavor, while allspice carries the essence of several spices. It’s a battle of the spices, and we’re in the middle.

Our grandmothers had it sorted, yet here we are, scratching our heads. Pimento seeds are not shy in Jamaican jerk seasoning. Allspice, on the other hand, plays it cool in pumpkin pies.

We’ve laughed over the confusion at many dinner tables. Now, it’s time we lay it out. Pimento vs. allspice: a tasty face-off.

What are Pimento Seeds?

Pimento seeds, aka allspice berries, come from the Pimenta dioica tree native to Jamaica and Central America.

These small brown seeds are strong-smelling and taste like a mix of cloves, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

They are popular in Caribbean and Latin American cooking for seasoning meats, stews, soups, and desserts.

Though recipes will sometimes use pimento and allspice interchangeably, they are not the same.

Pimento specifically refers to the dried fruit from the Pimenta dioica tree, while allspice is a blend of many spices, including pimento, cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg.

Allspice generally has a milder flavor than pure pimento.

Pimento oil is also extracted from the tree’s leaves and used in perfumes and medicine.

It is even the main ingredient in Jamaica’s famous jerk seasoning.

So, whether you’re using pimento or allspice in your cooking, or enjoying their scent in other products, they bring a special flavor and aroma to whatever they touch.

What is Allspice?

Allspice is a spice with a warm, fragrant flavor.

It is known for its unique blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

It comes from an evergreen tree native to the Caribbean and Central/South America.

Allspice is not just for cooking.

It has been used for medicinal purposes, such as treating indigestion and muscle pain.

These spices both have Caribbean warmth and fragrance, but have distinct differences in taste and smell.

Both allspice and pimento seeds can bring a unique flavor to your dishes.

Differences Between Pimento Seeds and Allspice

Pimento and allspice are often mistaken for each other.

Though they come from the same plant, they have different tastes.

Source and Appearance

Pimento seeds and allspice can be mistaken.

Pimento, also called Jamaican pepper, is sweet.

Allspice comes from the berry of a different plant.

This has a more complex flavor with a hint of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

Visually too, they are similar.

Both, pimento seeds and allspice, are small brown spheres that can be ground into powder.

Sometimes, pimento seeds are used in place of allspice in recipes.

But, the distinctive flavor of each spice means it doesn’t always work.

Understand the difference between pimento seeds and allspice and you’ll be an expert cook.

Experiment with flavor combos to make delicious meals.

Flavor and Aroma

Pimento seeds and allspice have different flavors and aromas.

Pimento is also known as allspice berries.

It has a warm taste with cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg notes.

Allspice has a complex taste with pepper, cloves, and cinnamon hints.

It’s essential to use these spices correctly when cooking.

Pimento is great for Jamaican jerk chicken or marinades due to its sweetness.

Allspice is more versatile.

It can be used in sweet pies or savory meat rubs.

Surprising fact.

Both pimento seeds and allspice come from the same tree.

They have different tastes, yet they share health benefits.

They help with digestion and reduce inflammation.

Culinary Uses and Applications

Pimento seeds and Allspice are two aromatic herbs used for flavoring.

Even though they come from different plants, they have a similar taste and smell.

Pimento seeds are native to Jamaica and come in dried berry form.

Allspice is from a tree called Pimenta dioica, mainly found in Central America and parts of Mexico.

In cooking, both are used in savory and sweet recipes.

Pimento seed is often used in jerk seasoning, while Allspice is an ingredient in pumpkin pies or tart fillings.

Medicinally, these spices hold value too.

Pimento seeds contain a natural analgesic called eugenol, which helps relieve pain.

Plus, Allspice has antioxidants to aid digestion and gut health.

These two ingredients can be easily confused.

But it’s important to tell them apart if you want to get the recipe right.

Similarities Between Pimento Seeds and Allspice

Pimento seeds and allspice aren’t the same.

But, they do have some similarities.

Both come from the same tree type.

Plus, they have similar tastes.

However, they have different textures and shapes.

Both are used in Caribbean cuisine.

A special thing about pimento seeds is they’re mostly used as a pickling spice.

For instance, you can combine it with vinegar to pickle foods like olives, peppers and veggies.

It’s also in Jamaican jerk seasoning.

Allspice is usually used for baking.

It has a sweet aroma and flavor.

The two spices come from different places.

Pimento seeds are from Central America and the Caribbean.

Allspice is from Jamaica but grown worldwide.

Despite the differences, both spices can give your cooking amazing flavor.

Knowing their similarities and differences helps you choose the right spice for your recipe.

Substituting Pimento Seeds for Allspice and Vice Versa

Pimento seeds and allspice – two flavors used in many cuisines.

But they look similar, yet are very different.

Allspice is made from the dried berry of the Pimenta dioica plant.

Whereas, the pimento seeds come from the same berry, but are not dried.

Can you use one instead of the other? Yes, but it might change the flavor.

Pimento seeds have a milder taste than allspice.

So, using them will give your dish a less spicy taste.

Using allspice instead will make it more intense.

But, note that these substitutes are not always the same.

If the recipe requires pimento seeds to be used whole, then ground allspice won’t work.

It has a different texture.

Plus, if the recipe needs ground allspice and you only have pimento seeds, then you must grind them before use.

Pimento seeds and allspice add depth and aroma to dishes.

Knowing their unique qualities will make your cooking turn out great.

So, don’t be scared to experiment with these flavorful spices.

Where to Buy Pimento Seeds and Allspice?

Curious as to where to get pimento seeds and allspice to spice up your dishes? Look no further.

Here are three ways to get your hands on these seasonings:

  • Amazon and Walmart offer an array of pimento seed and allspice options, with the ease of online shopping and delivery.
  • Your local supermarket might have them in the spice aisle or international section. Ask an employee if you can’t find them.
  • Spice shops in your area may have both whole pimento seeds and powdered allspice from around the world.

Keep in mind that although they have a similar taste, pimento seeds are from the Pimenta dioica tree, otherwise known as the allspice tree.

Allspice, however, is derived from the dried unripe berries of an evergreen tree found in Central America.

Knowing this can help you decide which spice is best for your recipe.

Now that you know where to buy pimento seeds and allspice, get going and try adding them to your next cuisine.

Your taste buds will be delighted.


Pimento seeds and allspice are often confused.

But they are completely different.

Pimento seeds come from the pimento tree.

Allspice comes from the dried berries of the Pimenta dioica plant.

In conclusion, even though pimento seeds and allspice are similar, they have unique flavors and uses in cooking.

Knowing the difference can help you make your recipes taste better.

Pimento Seeds vs Allspice: What’s the Difference?

Andrew Gray
Exploring spices to add depth to your dishes? Decode the disparities between pimento seeds and allspice, from their flavor profiles and culinary applications to their origins and availability.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That
Servings 1 Serving


  • Pimento Seeds
  • Allspice


  • Choose between pimento seeds and allspice based on your recipe requirements and flavor preferences.
  • Follow the recommended usage guidelines for your selected option, adding the appropriate amount to your dish.
  • Incorporate the pimento seeds or allspice into your recipe, ensuring they are well distributed.
  • Adjust the quantity as needed to achieve the desired taste and aroma.
  • Enjoy the distinct flavors and aromatic qualities that pimento seeds or allspice bring to your dish.
  • Experiment with different recipes to explore the versatility of each option.
Keyword Pimento Seeds vs Allspice
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating