Skip to Content

Plum Butter vs Plum Jam: What’s the Difference?

Have you ever been browsing the condiments aisle in your local grocery store and seen plum butter, only to wonder what exactly is the difference between it and a more-familiar product such as plum jam?

It can be confusing to come across two products that sound almost identical yet are significantly different.

If you’ve ever found yourself puzzled by this conundrum then worry no longer.

In this blog, we will explore the differences between plum butter and plum jam to help clear up any confusion around these two fruity condiments.

Read on for an in-depth look at ingredients, preparation techniques, flavor profiles and scientific facts about each of these tantalizing products.

What is Plum Butter?

Plum butter: a smooth, velvety spread.

Simmer plums, sugar and spices to get the rich, intense flavor.

The texture is luscious and it can be used for many purposes.

Making plum butter involves cooking plums, sugar and low heat.

Strain the mixture for a silky consistency.

Add spices like cinnamon or cloves for extra flavor.

Plum butter can be spread on toast or muffins for breakfast.

Or use it in cakes, tarts, or cookies for a fruity kick.

In savory dishes, it enhances meat glazes or marinades.

Plus, it’s a great accompaniment to cheese boards or charcuterie platters.

In conclusion: plum butter is a luxurious, versatile spread.

Enjoy it in sweet and savory dishes for a truly unique culinary experience.

What is Plum Jam?

Plum jam is a delicious treat.

It’s made from plums that have been cooked with sugar and maybe some lemon juice.

The plums break down and form a smooth and thick spread with sweet and tangy flavors.

It’s popular for breakfast or in recipes.

Enjoy it on toast, scones, or as a filling in pastries and cakes.

Plums and sugar make a balanced flavor profile that’s yummy and comforting.

You can make your own or buy it from a store.

Let’s learn more about this jam.

Different types of plums give it different characteristics.

For instance, European plums are dark purple and Japanese plums are yellow.

These all contribute to the jam’s complexity.

Making plum jam involves chopping the plums, simmering them with sugar over low heat, and maybe adding spices like cinnamon or nutmeg.

Differences Between Plum Butter and Plum Jam

Plum butter and jam – both made from plums.

But they have differences.

Plum butter is thick and velvety.

It’s made by cooking down plums.

Ingredients Used

Plums can be turned into yummy spreads.

Two options are plum butter and jam.

They share a base but differ in other ingredients and how they’re made.

Plum butter is cooked slowly, just using plums and a sweetener such as sugar or honey.

This caramelizes the natural sugars, giving a rich flavor.

No extra spices are added.

Plum jam has more ingredients.

Along with plums and sweetener, lemon juice and pectin (a thickening agent) are included.

Sometimes, spices like cinnamon or nutmeg are added too.

Which one to choose? That’s personal preference.

Plum butter gives a concentrated, pure taste.

Jam is more complex with a hint of citrus and spices.

Both are great ways to enjoy fresh plums.

Cooking Process and Consistency

Plum butter and jam may appear alike, yet they differ in their making process and texture.

Butter involves slow-cooking plums with sugar, lemon juice and spices, till they become a soft spread.

It’s simmered for a long time, to allow the flavors to intensify.

Jam is made by boiling plums with pectin and sugar until it gels.

This retains chunks of fruit, making it chunky and fruity.

These two spreads, while similar in ingredients, vary in their cooking techniques.

Butter takes longer, for a smoother texture, while jam takes less time to maintain its chunkiness.

The slow-cooking of butter also gives it more flavor.

The consistency is another major difference.

Butter is velvety and glides on bread or crackers, with sweet and tangy flavors.

Jam has a textured feel, with pieces of cooked fruit in its jelly-like form.

Its thicker consistency adds a nice bite.

Flavor Profile and Taste

Plum butter & plum jam have distinct differences in taste & flavor.

Plum butter has a rich, velvety texture & deep sweet taste.

It’s made by slowly cooking plums with sugar, spices, & sometimes lemon juice or zest.

This process amplifies the natural sweetness & creates a unique flavor.

Plum jam stands out with its tartness & sweetness.

Spread it on toast or use it to make thumbprint cookies or tarts.

Its vibrant flavor adds brightness to any dish.

Despite using the same star ingredient, plum butter & jam offer different experiences.

Butter offers an intense flavor with a velvety texture.

Jam appeals to those who appreciate tartness & sweetness.

Both give a delightful burst of fruity goodness.

Sugar Content and Sweetness Level

When it comes to sugar and sweetness, Plum Butter and Plum Jam are different.

Both are made from plums, but their sugar content can vary.

Plum Butter has less sugar because it’s made by slowly cooking plums without adding much extra sugar.

This results in a milder, less sugary taste.

On the other hand, Plum Jam is made with plums and more sugar.

This gives it a sweeter taste.

Also, the sugar content impacts the sweetness.

Plum Butter has a subtle, delicate sweetness.

Plum Jam has a bolder, stronger sweet taste.

Think about your sweet tooth when choosing between them.

Both are great for toast or desserts.

Similarities Between Plum Butter and Plum Jam

Plum butter and jam are similar.

Both are yummy, made from plums and sugar, with the same purpose: to keep plum flavor for a long time.

And both can be used on toast or in pastries.

Making them includes cooking the fruit and sugar, creating a thick, sweet mix.

These similarities make either one a great choice to savor plums.

However, there are details that set plum butter apart.

It is silkier than jam due to the longer cooking time that lets the fruit break down more.

This makes it great for spreading on bread or biscuits.

Plum jam still has pieces of fruit that give a burst of flavor in each bite.

Uses and Serving Suggestions for Plum Butter and Plum Jam

Plum butter and plum jam differ in use and serving.

Plum butter is great for toast and muffins.

Plum jam shines in pastries, tarts, cakes, and more.

Plum butter’s flavor works well with savory dishes, like glazes and cheese platters.

Plum jam is a popular baking ingredient due to its thick texture and fruity taste.

Enjoy either on its own, or mix into yogurt and oatmeal.

Unleash your culinary creativity with these yummy plum preserves.


As we can see, there are clear differences between plum butter and plum jam.

Plum butter has a creamier consistency, a more complex flavor profile, a nuttier texture and is cooked for far longer than when making jam.

It also tends to use more fruit and often even includes additional ingredients like cinnamon or cardamom.

On the other hand, jams tend to have a thicker consistency with little chunks of fruit left over whereas butters use either pureed or mashed fruits as their base ingredient.

Also, jams typically require much less cooking time since the higher sugar content creates an interior vacuum which helps them set quicker.

After learning about the various differences between these two products, it is now easier than ever to make an informed decision when deciding which one best satisfies your culinary needs.

While both products will always remain popular due to their delicious tastes and unique textures, it is worth further investigating them so that you can gain a better understanding of each one’s merits and ultimately choose the right one for your next baking adventure.

Plum Butter vs Plum Jam: What’s the Difference?

Distinguishing between plum butter and plum jam? Look no further! Discover the precise differences between the two with our concise guide.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That


  • Plum Butter
  • Plum Jam


  • Choose between plum butter and plum jam based on your preference.
  • Follow the respective recipe for your chosen option.
  • Prepare your plums and other ingredients accordingly.
  • Cook and process the mixture as instructed for either plum butter or plum jam.
  • Enjoy the delicious spread on your favorite dishes, whether you prefer the smooth richness of plum butter or the chunky sweetness of plum jam.
Keyword Plum Butter vs Plum Jam
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating