Skip to Content

Roy Rogers Drink vs Shirley Temple: Which is a Better Option?

Debating the superior mocktail? Roy Rogers versus Shirley Temple. Two giants in the non-alcoholic ring. We’ve all been there. A sunny afternoon, craving something sweet, but water just won’t do.

Enter the Roy Rogers. Cherry. Cola. Ice. Simple, yet iconic. Then there’s the Shirley Temple. Ginger ale meets grenadine, topped with a maraschino cherry. Childhood in a glass.

We remember that first sip. The sweetness hits, nostalgia floods. Each has its loyal fans. Ours? Well, read on to find out.

What is a Roy Rogers Drink?

A popular non-alcoholic drink is the Roy Rogers, made of coke and grenadine syrup.

It’s a sweet concoction that can be enjoyed by all ages.

This drink originated in the United States and was named after the famous cowboy actor.

Despite its simple ingredients, it has gained popularity among those who want an alternative to traditional sodas or juices.

The drink is also known as a Virgin Cuba Libre or Cherry Cola and can easily be prepared at home or enjoyed at a restaurant.

What makes the Roy Rogers unique is the addition of grenadine syrup which gives it a distinctive red color and fruity taste.

The grenadine also adds sweetness and complements the carbonated coke.

For those who prefer less sweetness, they can adjust the amount of syrup added to suit their taste preference.

The drink is often served with ice and garnished with a cherry on top.

What is a Shirley Temple?

Shirley Temple is a non-alcoholic mixed drink that is perfect for people who prefer not to consume alcohol.

It is a sweet and fruity cocktail that has become very popular in recent times.

If you are someone who likes to enjoy a refreshing drink, then you may want to give Shirley Temple a try.

  • Shirley Temple was named after the famous child actress of the same name.
  • The drink originated in the 1930s when she was making movies.
  • The original recipe called for ginger ale, grenadine and a splash of orange juice.
  • Today, it is often made with lemon-lime soda instead of ginger ale and maraschino cherries are added for garnish.
  • A variation of this drink can be made using Sprite or 7-Up instead of lemon-lime soda.
  • Some recipes call for additional ingredients such as pineapple juice, lime juice or even coconut rum to give it an extra tropical twist.

For those who do not care much for alcohol, Shirley Temple is an excellent choice.

Besides being delicious, it is also visually appealing because of its bright red color and garnishing with cherries.

While some might find it too sweet or fruity, its unique taste makes it stand out amongst other non-alcoholic drinks.

Ingredients Used in Roy Rogers Drink and Shirley Temple

The beverages Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple are popular among both alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinkers.

The ingredients used in these drinks play a significant role in creating the perfect balance of flavors.

Roy Rogers consists of cola syrup, grenadine, and soda water.

It is then garnished with a maraschino cherry, making it a simple yet appealing drink for people who prefer non-alcoholic beverages.

On the other hand, Shirley Temple has ginger ale or lemon-lime soda mixed with grenadine and is later garnished with a maraschino cherry and orange slice.

This drink is mostly enjoyed by children but also preferred by some adults.

What makes these drinks stand out is their unique blend of flavors that not only please the taste buds but also give an aesthetic look to the drinker due to its presentation.

Flavor and Taste Comparison between Roy Rogers Drink and Shirley Temple

Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple drinks are two popular non-alcoholic beverages.

While both are quite similar, they differ slightly in their ingredients and taste.

The Roy Rogers drink is a combination of cola and grenadine syrup, while the Shirley Temple is made using lemon-lime soda and grenadine syrup.

The former has a stronger flavor because of the cola, while the latter offers a more refreshing and less sweet taste.

The Roy Rogers drink has a cherry undertone that blends well with the cola, which makes it somewhat similar to a cherry Coke.

Meanwhile, the Shirley Temple has a subtle fruity flavor with hints of pomegranate thanks to the grenadine syrup mixed in.

In terms of appearance, both drinks look appealing with bright colors that make them perfect for parties or for people who seek eye-catching beverages.

If you prefer an intense flavor profile with strong carbonation, then Roy Rogers is an excellent option for you.

However, suppose you lean towards lightness in flavors without excessive sweetness at any given time of day; in that case, Shirley Temple is your go-to beverage choice.

Ultimately both drinks offer distinct flavors worth giving a try when looking for an awesome drink treat.

Sweetness Level and Sugar Content Comparison

Comparing the Sweetness Levels and Sugar Contents of the Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple drinks is important for those seeking a healthier option.

The Roy Rogers, made with cola and grenadine, contains 32 grams of sugar per serving while the Shirley Temple, made with ginger ale and grenadine, contains 23 grams of sugar per serving.

Despite being known as mocktails, they still have high sugar content which can lead to weight gain and other health issues.

It is recommended to limit consumption or opt for a no-sugar-added alternative.

Alcohol-Free Options: Roy Rogers vs Shirley Temple

Looking for a non-alcoholic drink that is both delicious and refreshing?

Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple are two classic options that have stood the test of time.

The Roy Rogers cocktail is made with cola and grenadine syrup, while the Shirley Temple contains ginger ale, grenadine syrup and maraschino cherry.

Both drinks are perfect for those who want to enjoy a flavorful beverage without the presence of alcohol.

They can be served at any social gathering or enjoyed as a solo treat.

What sets Roy Rogers apart from Shirley Temple is its unique blend of cola and grenadine flavors.

This drink is generally favored by those who prefer a sweeter taste with subtle hints of fruity flavors.

On the other hand, Shirley Temple tends to be more popular for its effervescence and lighter flavor profile.

Ginger ale adds a sharp tang to this drink, which is balanced out by the sweet taste of grenadine syrup.

Ultimately, choosing between Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple comes down to personal preference.

Both drinks are timeless classics that offer a delightful drinking experience without alcohol.

So go ahead and take your pick.

Variations and Customizations of Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple

The diverse blends of Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple drinks are essential for a satisfying experience.

The customization options are boundless, and every variation has its distinct flavor that caters to different tastes.

Individuals may personalize their Roy Rogers Drink with unique flavors such as raspberry, lime or ginger ale.

Alternatively, they can tailor the Shirley Temple drink to meet their preferences with additions like orange juice or caramel syrup.

Furthermore, a combination of both can be an excellent choice for those who seek a mix of both sweet and sour flavors.

Another option includes specifying the sweetness level of the drink by adjusting the grenadine quantity.

In essence, there are limitless variations and customizations available when selecting between Roy Rogers and Shirley Temple drinks.

Try them out to discover your taste preference and tailor them according to it.

Popular Brands and Variants

This article explores different popular beverage options and their variants.

One such variant is the Roy Rogers drink, often made with cola and grenadine syrup.

Another popular option is the Shirley Temple, made with ginger ale and grenadine syrup.

Both options are non-alcoholic and suitable for all ages.

While both drinks are enjoyable, it ultimately comes down to personal preference in terms of taste and appearance.

Nevertheless, these classic beverages have stood the test of time and continue to be beloved by many.


After analyzing the nutritional value, taste, and presentation of Roy Rogers Drink and Shirley Temple, it can be said that both options have their own distinctive qualities.

However, in terms of nutrition and calories, Shirley Temple is a better option as it contains less sugar compared to Roy Rogers Drink which has high sugar content.

On the other hand, Roy Rogers Drink is a perfect choice if you want to indulge in a more vibrant and flavorful drink.

Ultimately, the decision depends on your personal preferences and dietary needs.

One thing to keep in mind is that consuming beverages with high sugar content regularly may increase the risk of developing health issues such as obesity, diabetes, and tooth decay.

Therefore, it’s important to consider limiting the intake of such drinks.

Roy Rogers Drink vs Shirley Temple: Which is a Better Option?

Andrew Gray
Looking for a refreshing mocktail? Let's compare Roy Rogers Drink and Shirley Temple to determine which is the better option for your non-alcoholic beverage choice.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That
Servings 1 Serving


  • Roy Rogers Drink
  • Shirley Temple


  • Choose between two items based on your preference and availability.
  • Follow the cooking directions for your chosen option, using the appropriate ratio of ingredients.
  • Prepare it according to your desired recipes.
  • Incorporate them into your dish, adjusting the amount to suit your taste.
  • Enjoy the unique taste experience and experiment with different dishes to explore their versatility.
Keyword Roy Rogers Drink vs Shirley Temple
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!