Skip to Content

Sweet Delights: 5 BEST Rum Extract Substitutes

Rum extract’s a game-changer in baking, isn’t it?

We’ve all been there, mid-recipe, and boom—no rum extract in the pantry.

What do we do? Ditch the recipe? No way!

We’ve got the scoop on the top five rum extract substitutes to save your dessert.

These swaps aren’t just backups; they can make your treats taste even better.

Finding a good substitute isn’t a hit or miss—it’s about knowing the vibe of your dessert.

Each option we’ll cover has its unique flair.

Some keep it close to the original, others spin the flavor wheel.

And that’s exciting because who doesn’t love a tasty plot twist in their baking saga?

The 5 Best Substitutes for Rum Extract

You have several options if you’re looking for a rum extract substitute.

Below are some of the best substitutes for rum extract:

1 – Vanilla Extract

vanilla extract

Vanilla extract is a popular flavoring used in many desserts, such as cakes, cookies, and ice cream.

It is made by soaking vanilla beans in alcohol, which extracts the flavor from the beans.

Vanilla extract has a long history, dating back to the Aztecs, who used it to flavor their chocolate drinks.

Today, it is widely used in many cuisines around the world.

The taste of vanilla extract is sweet and slightly floral.

It is also one of the most versatile flavors, as it pairs well with both sweet and savory dishes.

In addition to its use in desserts, vanilla extract can also be used to flavor savory dishes, such as chicken or pork.

Vanilla extract can also be used in place of rum extract in baking recipes.

This is a good option for those who do not like the taste of rum or for those who are looking for a less potent alcohol flavor.

Vanilla extract can be found in most grocery stores.

It is typically sold in small bottles and is fairly inexpensive.

However, it can also be found in larger sizes at some specialty stores.

2 – Bourbon


Bourbon is a type of American whiskey that is made from corn.

It originates from the state of Kentucky and has a history that dates back to the 18th century.

The taste of bourbon is typically sweet, with notes of vanilla and caramel.

It is often used in mixed drinks and cocktails.

One reason to consider substituting bourbon for rum extract is that it can add a unique flavor to your recipe.

Bourbon also has a lower alcohol content than rum, so it can be a good option if you are looking to reduce the amount of alcohol in your dish.

Additionally, bourbon can be a less expensive alternative to rum extract.

3 – Plain Rum

plain rum

While rum is typically associated with tropical drinks like daiquiris and piña coladas, it can also be enjoyed on its own.

Plain rum is a type of distilled alcohol made from sugarcane juice or molasses.

It originates from the Caribbean, where it was first produced in the 1600s.

Rum has a sweet, rich flavor with notes of vanilla and caramel.

It can be enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or mixed into cocktails.

Plain rum can also be used as a cooking ingredient, as it adds a unique sweetness and depth of flavor to dishes.

When substituting rum for other ingredients like rum extract, keep in mind that it is much more potent.

You will need to use less rum to achieve the same flavor profile.

Whether you’re sipping it straight or using it in your favorite recipe, plain rum is a versatile option that is sure to please.

4 – Coconut Rum

coconut rum

Coconut rum is a type of rum that uses coconut milk or cream as its base.

It is typically made by infusing rum with the flavor of coconut, though some brands also use artificial flavors.

Coconut rum originated in the Caribbean, where it is still popular today.

The first recorded mention of coconut rum dates back to 1650 when English explorer Johnathan Dickenson noted its use among the residents of Barbados.

Coconut rum is usually clear or pale in color and has a sweet, coconutty flavor.

It can be enjoyed on its own or used in cocktails such as piño Coladas and daiquiris.

Many people prefer coconut rum to traditional rum because it has a milder flavor and is less likely to cause hangovers.

For this reason, it is often used as a substitute for rum extract in baking and other recipes.

5 – Tequila


Tequila is a type of mezcal and the national drink of Mexico.

It is made from the blue agave plant, which is native to the state of Jalisco in Mexico.

The plants are typically harvested after seven to ten years, and the resulting juice is distilled to produce tequila.

The most common type of tequila is silver, or Blanco, which is bottled immediately after distillation.

Other types of tequila include reposado, which is aged for two to twelve months in oak barrels, and añejo, which is aged for more than one year.

Tequila can be enjoyed straight or in a variety of cocktails, such as Margaritas and Palomas.

While tequila is traditionally made with 100% agave juice, some brands may use up to 49% of other sugars, such as cane sugar or honey.

As a result, these tequilas may have a sweeter taste.

If you are looking for a substitute for rum extract, consider using tequila instead.

It will provide the same sweetness without overpowering the other flavors in your recipe.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Rum Extract

Looking for alternatives to rum extract? Look no further! We've compiled a precise list of the 5 best substitutes to enhance your recipes without rum extract.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Vanilla Extract
  • Bourbon
  • Plain Rum
  • Coconut Rum
  • Tequila


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword best substitutes for rum extract
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating