Skip to Content

Russet vs Idaho Potatoes: Which is a Better Option?

Do you know the difference between a russet and an Idaho potato?

While in the grocery store picking up potatoes for your favorite recipes, you often see both varieties side by side with no hint as to their differences.

Sure, one is most likely slightly more expensive than the other but why should you paying it?

Can’t you just use any type of potato for all of your dishes? The answer might surprise you.

To make informed decisions about which type of potato will best fulfill your needs in cooking, read this article and learn about the detailed distinctions between these two popular potato varieties.

What are Russet Potatoes?

Russet potatoes are a specific type of potato that is popularly used in various recipes globally.

These potatoes are commonly known for their brown outer skin, which is rough to touch and thick, while the inner part has white flesh.

Also known as Idaho potatoes, Russet potatoes are widely recognized for their high starch content, making them an ideal choice for baking, mashing, or frying.

When cooked correctly, Russet potatoes produce fluffy mashed potatoes with no lumps and crispy French fries with a golden texture.

Due to their unique texture and taste, Russets are a favorite among chefs who use them to make hash browns or baked potato wedges.

There are several varieties of Russet potatoes available in the market.

However, most famous ones include Burbank Russet and Norkotah Russet.

While Burbank Russet is mostly grown in North America and Chile, Norkotah is predominantly grown in the US state of Idaho.

What are Idaho Potatoes?

Idaho potatoes are a type of potato grown in the state of Idaho that is known for its distinctive taste and texture.

These potatoes are oval-shaped and have a brownish skin with white flesh inside.

They are popular for making French fries, mashed potatoes, and baked potatoes due to their high starch content.

In addition to their culinary uses, Idaho potatoes are also packed with nutrients such as fiber, vitamin C, and potassium.

They are also low in fat and calories, making them a healthy option for those looking to maintain a balanced diet.

One key difference between Idaho potatoes and other types of potatoes, such as Russet potatoes, is how they are grown.

Idaho potatoes are typically grown in well-drained volcanic soil that is rich in nutrients, which contributes to their unique flavor and texture.

Overall, whether you choose Russet or Idaho potatoes depends on your personal preferences and what you plan on using them for.

However, if you’re looking for a high-quality potato that is packed with nutrients and has a delicious taste, then Idaho potatoes may be the way to go.

Differences Between Russet and Idaho Potatoes

Russet potatoes and Idaho potatoes are popular choices in the potato family.

The two varieties have several distinguishing features that make them unique.

When considering these potatoes, it is essential to understand their differences to make an informed choice.

Origin and History

Potatoes have an intriguing set of origins and history.

Their exact origin is not precisely defined, but we know that the Inca tribe first cultivated them in the Andean mountains of Peru, Bolivia, and Chile.

It is believed that potatoes were first introduced to Europe through Spain in the 16th century.

From there, they eventually spread worldwide as a staple crop, with global demand rising.

Today, potatoes are a significant ingredient used in various cuisines around the world.

When it comes to Russet and Idaho potatoes, their history dates back to mid-1800s America.

Henry Harmon Spalding was one of Oregon’s early settlers who planted potato seedlings on his farm.

Spalding traded some of these seeds with the Idaho Agriculture Experiment Station (AES).

These seeds then found their way into commercial production: Russet Burbank potato variety became popular globally due to its excellent ability to produce high yields.

There are unique differences between Russet and Idaho potatoes that make them stand out from each other.

For instance, while both have russet skin, the Russet Burbank tends to be elongated and large while also having a higher sugar content than most other varieties of Idaho potatoes.

On the other hand, Potatoes that fall under “Idaho” tend to have a firm texture and evenly shallow eyes making them ideal for baking or frying.

Interestingly enough, according to recent statistics over 50% of US household consumers claim more purchase decisions are made based on their health-focused regulations such as Non-GMO verified/sourced produce options being available opposed conventional farming practices which could possibly eliminate pesticide residue affects on consumption behavior patterns among these households when selecting either Russet vs Idaho Potatoes.

Appearance and Texture

Potatoes are often judged by their overall appearance and texture, and these factors can influence a person’s decision on which variety to purchase.

Both russet and Idaho potatoes have distinct appearances and textures that can be compared and contrasted.

Russets have a thicker skin and tend to be more oval-shaped, while Idaho potatoes are typically longer and may have smoother skin.

In terms of texture, russets tend to be drier and fluffier when cooked, while Idaho potatoes have a creamier texture.

When it comes to cooking methods, these differences in appearance and texture can impact the outcome of your dish.

If you’re making mashed potatoes or potato soup, for example, you might prefer using russets for their dryness, which will absorb liquid easily without becoming overly mushy.

On the other hand, if you’re making roasted or baked potatoes that require a slightly creamier texture, Idaho potatoes might be a better option.

It’s also worth noting that both varieties can have variations in appearance and texture depending on where they are grown and how they are prepared.

For example, potatoes grown in certain regions may have denser flesh than those grown elsewhere, while cooking methods like frying vs boiling can impact the final texture.

Ultimately, deciding between russet vs Idaho potatoes comes down to personal preference and the intended use of the potato in your recipe.

Consider the desired texture of your dish and experiment with different varieties to find the best fit for you.

Flavor and Taste

Potatoes are known for their unique and delicious flavor that varies depending on the type.

When it comes to the subjective aspect of taste, both russet and Idaho potatoes provide a rich and satisfactory experience.

The choice between the two solely depends on personal preference, recipe requirements, and consistency.

Both potatoes have a mellow and earthy flavor with subtle notes of sweetness.

However, Russet potatoes tend to be denser with a slightly nutty taste compared to Idaho potatoes which are fluffier in texture with a mild buttery taste.

The difference in taste can be attributed to their starch content as russet potatoes have higher levels, thus ideal for baking or frying while the lower starch levels in Idaho potatoes make them excellent for boiling or roasting.

In comparison, Russets have thicker skin that adds a crispy texture when fried or baked while Idaho has thin skin making it ideal for mashed potatoes or boiled meals like stews.

Taste preferences should also consider factors such as health benefits where Idaho offers more nutrients like vitamin C and fiber than Russets though Russets have higher potassium levels.

Nutrition and Health Benefits

Potatoes are a common food item in most households, with Russet and Idaho being the two popular types.

Potatoes are essential for our nutrition and health benefits.

Here’s what you need to know about the benefits of consuming them.

  • Both potatoes provide adequate nutrients like potassium, vitamin C, fiber, and iron.
  • Idaho potatoes have more protein and less fat content compared to Russet Potatoes.
  • Russet potatoes have a lower glycemic index which is great for people with diabetes or insulin resistance.
  • Idaho potatoes contain resistant starch which promotes gut health and reduces the risk of colon cancer.

It’s also important to note that while both Russet and Idaho potatoes have similar nutritional benefits, they do differ slightly in terms of taste and texture.

Choosing one over the other may boil down to personal preference.

Overall, including either of these potatoes in your diet can bring excellent nutrition and health benefits.

Along with the nutritional benefits mentioned above, it’s crucial to consider how potatoes are cooked.

Fried or processed potato dishes may negate or even reverse some of these benefits.

Opting for boiled or roasted potato dishes can ensure maximum nutritional intake without any adverse effects on health.

Similarities Between Russet and Idaho Potatoes

Russet and Idaho potatoes share several similarities in texture, taste, and cooking versatility.

Both types of potatoes have a brown skin and white flesh inside.

They are starchy, making them great for baking, frying, boiling, and mashing.

Moreover, russet and Idaho potatoes are a good source of Vitamin C and potassium.

These vegetables can be used interchangeably in most recipes.

In terms of differences between these potatoes, one thing stands out: geography.

Russet is grown worldwide, while Idaho is specifically grown in Idaho state in the USA under strict regulations to ensure high-quality production standards and consistency.

Additionally, the skins of Idaho potatoes are smoother than russets.

This makes them ideal for dishes where their flavor contributes significantly.

Overall, both Russet and Idaho potatoes are popular choices for various culinary applications due to their excellent skin-to-flesh ratio that produces crispy french fries or smooth mashed potatoes with ease.

The choice between the two largely boils down to personal preference and recipe requirements rather than inherent superiority of one over the other.

Cooking Methods for Russet and Idaho Potatoes

Potatoes are an essential ingredient in many dishes.

Various types of potatoes are available on the market, and Russet and Idaho potatoes are two popular variants.

Understanding the cooking methods for these potatoes is vital to achieve the best results in your dish.

When it comes to cooking methods for Russet and Idaho potatoes, there are several options available.

The common ways include baking, boiling, frying, or mashing them.

However, each of these methods requires different preparation techniques and conditions.

For instance, if you want to bake Russet or Idaho potatoes, you need to ensure that they are clean and dry before placing them in the oven.

Similarly, boiling Russet potatoes can take longer than Idaho because of its starch content.

The fries made from Russet and Idaho have different textures and tastes due to their respective starch levels.

It’s essential to understand which type of potato suits your recipe better; a mashed potato dish may require a warm Idaho potato over a dryer Russet.

Always consider what method that specific potato type excels at (e.


, frying) before intending on using it.


Comparing Russet and Idaho potatoes is a complex decision, as both varieties have their unique benefits and drawbacks.

Russets are ideal for baking, frying, or making mashed potatoes due to their high starch levels, while Idaho spuds are versatile and work well in various recipes.

Factors such as taste, texture, and nutrition also play a crucial role in deciding the best option for one’s dietary needs.

Ultimately, it boils down to individual preferences and usage.

Russet vs Idaho Potatoes: Which is a Better Option?

Preparing potatoes for your favorite recipes? Russet and Idaho potatoes are popular choices, but they vary in starch content and texture when cooked. Explore the characteristics of each potato variety to select the option that achieves your desired culinary results.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That
Servings 1 Serving


  • Russet Potatoes
  • Idaho Potatoes


  • Choose between two items based on your preference and availability.
  • Follow the cooking directions for your chosen option, using the appropriate ratio of ingredients.
  • Prepare it according to your desired recipes.
  • Incorporate them into your dish, adjusting the amount to suit your taste.
  • Enjoy the unique taste experience and experiment with different dishes to explore their versatility.
Keyword Russet vs Idaho Potatoes
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!