Skip to Content

10 BEST Sauces for Polenta to Consider

Searching for the best sauce to top off your polenta dish can be a daunting task.

With seemingly endless possibilities, how can you make sure you are picking the perfect option?

Knowing exactly what to look for when choosing your sauce can help you come to an informed and tasty decision.

This article will discuss 10 of the best sauces for polenta that you should consider so that you make the optimal choice for any occasion.

By exploring each of these high-quality options, you can make sure that each bite is bursting with flavor.

Why Spices are Important for Polenta?

Adding spices to polenta can take the dish from just a side to a flavorful main entrée.

Not only do spices provide a unique and memorable depth of flavor, but they also create a healthier option for those looking for a delicious way to eat polenta.

Spices have been used medicinally around the world for centuries and are known to have powerful antioxidant properties that help ward off disease and protect the body.

By adding spices like chili powder, cumin, coriander, oregano, basil, thyme, smoked paprika and turmeric you can instantly upgrade your polenta dishes.

These classic spices lend an exciting flavor profile that pairs so well with creamy polenta dishes like risotto-style polenta bowls or skillet-fried croquettes.

For an extra punch of flavor try adding chorizo or herbs such as dill or sage.

The varieties of spices and herbs you can use for polenta are almost endless.

Experiment with various combinations until you find something that really speaks to your taste buds.

Criteria for Choosing the Best Sauces

Polenta is a versatile Italian specialty that goes well with a variety of sauces.

Whether you’re serving it as an appetizer, side dish, main course or even dessert, having a great sauce to accompany it can take the dish from mundane to memorable.

To help you find the perfect pairing, keep these criteria in mind when selecting the best sauce for polenta.

First and foremost, flavor is key.

While some ingredients work together naturally, there are no hard and fast rules when it comes to sauce selection.

It’s best to experiment until you find the combinations that please your palate.

Consider things like texture, taste and aroma when considering sauces for your polenta dish.

The type of polenta is also important when specifying a sauce—traditional boiled cornmeal or creamy baked varieties both require special consideration for their respective sauces.

Additionally, versatility matters—are you looking for something hearty and chunky to draw out the richness of your dishes? Or maybe a lighter, creamier sauce? Selecting one (or several) with broader appeal makes meal prepping and planning a cinch.

Finally, don’t forget presentation.

A truly unforgettable dish often comes down to its presentation; choose sauces that enhance all the components on your plate aesthetically as well as taste-wise.

Taking on these points before deciding on your perfect polenta pairing will help ensure delicious success every time.

10 BEST Sauces for Polenta to Consider

1. Mushroom Sauce

Mushroom sauce is one of the classic ways to dress up polenta.

It features an earthy flavor without being too heavy.

To prepare it, you’ll need butter, button mushrooms, garlic, fresh thyme leaves and white wine.

As for the polenta, feel free to use either the quick-cooking variety or the traditional stone-ground version — both work equally well.

All you have to do is melt half of the butter in a pan and sauté the mushrooms until they are golden brown.

Add in some minced garlic, a few sprigs of thyme and white wine before simmering everything together until it reduces into a thick sauce.

The last step is simply stirring in the remaining butter and serving over your freshly cooked polenta with freshly chopped parsley as garnish.

2. San Marzano Tomato Sauce

San Marzano tomatoes are an Italian variety of plum tomatoes, known for their sweet and juicy flavor.

Their use in Italian cooking has become popular all over the world.

When making a San Marzano tomato sauce, you can use canned or fresh tomatoes.

For the best flavor, look for canned San Marzano tomatoes with the DOP designation (Protected Denomination of Origin).

This certification guarantees that the tomatoes have been grown in designated areas around Naples and are much sweeter than other tomato varieties.

To make a simple San Marzano tomato sauce to serve with polenta consider adding olive oil, onions, garlic, basil, oregano, red pepper flakes and salt to taste.

Simmer for about 20 minutes until everything is softened and combined.

Serve warm over creamy polenta for a delicious and comforting meal.

3. Blue Cheese Sauce

Polenta is a classic dish from Italy that can be served in many different ways.

It’s a great vehicle for all sorts of sauces, from tomato to pesto to blue cheese.

The blue cheese sauce shines with its pungent, creamy and flavorful mix of ingredients here.

To make it, you’ll need butter, cream, blue cheese and white wine to add some acidity for balance.

Begin by heating up the butter until it’s melted.

Then add the cream and bring to a gentle simmer before reducing the heat and stirring in crumbled blue cheese until it has fully melted into the sauce.

Finally, pour in the white wine at the end for a bright finish and season with salt and pepper as desired.

Serve this delicious creamy sauce over hot polenta or use as a dip for vegetables or fried foods—the possibilities are endless.

4. White Wine Lemon Caper Sauce

White Wine Lemon Caper Sauce is a classic sauce that pairs perfectly with a creamy, cheesy polenta.

The sauce is made from white wine, butter, lemon juice, and capers.

The result is an incredibly flavorful and light sauce that brings out the flavors of the polenta.

Perfect for serving alongside grilled meats or poultry as well as fish, this sauce is sure to be a crowd pleaser.

Try adding fresh herbs and red pepper flakes for an extra zing of flavor.

5. Puttanesca Sauce

Puttanesca sauce is a traditional Italian sauce that has a delicious combination of tangy, salty, and briny flavors.

It is usually prepared with tomatoes, olives, capers, garlic, oregano and anchovies.

The sauce is a flavorful accompaniment to many dishes but it can be especially delicious when served over polenta.

It’s flavorful enough to stand up to the creamy texture of polenta while offering an interesting contrast of flavors to the subtle taste of this traditional dish.

Try it with some fresh Parmesan cheese sprinkled on top.

6. Creamy Garlic Sauce

Creamy garlic sauce is a delicious and easy topping for polenta that only takes minutes to make.

This sauce combines butter, minced garlic, pepper, Parmesan cheese and half-and-half to create a flavorful, creamy and smooth topping.

Simply melt the butter in a medium saucepan over low heat, add the garlic and cook until softened before stirring in the pepper and Parmesan cheese.

Once these ingredients are combined, slowly stream in the half-and-half while stirring continuously until your desired consistency is reached.

Serve hot over warm polenta for an irresistible meal.

7. Red Onion Gravy

Red onion gravy is a delicious favorite for polenta lovers.

This sauce has a rich and earthy flavor that brings out the best of polenta’s creamy texture.

To prepare it, start by cooking some diced red onion in butter or olive oil until nicely caramelized.

Season with a pinch of sugar and some fresh herbs, then pour in either a beef or vegetable stock and simmer uncovered for 15 minutes on low heat.

Add a tablespoon of cream for an extra smooth finish and serve with your polenta.

8. Marinara Sauce

Marinara sauce is a classic Italian tomato-based sauce that can be used to dress up polenta in a fraction of the time it takes to make a homemade marinara.

It usually contains garlic, oregano, basil and olives, although ingredients may vary by brand.

To prepare the marinara, heat some olive oil in a saucepan and add garlic and onion powder.

Cook for about a minute then pour in the marinara sauce and simmer for about 5 minutes.

Stir in grated Parmesan cheese before serving with your favorite polenta dish.

9. Pesto

Pesto is a classic Italian sauce made with basil, garlic, pine nuts and Parmesan cheese.

It is best used as a finishing sauce and can be served warm or cold.

Pesto is the perfect compliment to polenta and brings out its subtle flavor in an amazing way.

Use it as a topping for grilled polenta slices or as a condiment to liven up your creamy dish.

For extra flavor, you could also add lemon juice or other herbs like oregano or thyme.

10. Sriracha Hot Sauce

This sauce is a great addition to polenta as it adds an intense and flavorful heat that is still manageable.

Sriracha Hot Sauce’s combination of sweet and salty flavors makes it ideal for adding an extra dimension of flavor to your polenta dish.

It is made from a combination of chili peppers, vinegar, garlic, sugar, and salt and can be used as a condiment or even added to salads and soups for added spice.

Be sure to start off with just a few dashes until you find the right amount that agrees with your taste buds.


To finish, it’s important to remember that polenta is a versatile accompaniment that pairs well with a number of flavors.

Experimentation in the kitchen can often lead to unexpected and delicious results.

It’s impossible to find one sauce or topping combo that will work with every recipe, but by understanding these 10 great options, you can easily find an accompaniment that will bring out the best in your polenta.

From classic Italian arrabbiata sauce to barbeque baked beans, there’s something for everyone and all dietary preferences.

Whether you choose to top your polenta with vegetables, proteins, or sauces you can be sure of one thing – it will taste amazing.

10 BEST Sauces for Polenta to Consider

Elevate your polenta game with these 10 exceptional sauces that add a burst of flavor and sophistication to this versatile Italian staple.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course Side Dishes
Servings 1 Serving


  • 1. Mushroom Sauce
  • 2. San Marzano Tomato Sauce
  • 3. Blue Cheese Sauce
  • 4. White Wine Lemon Caper Sauce
  • 5. Puttanesca Sauce
  • 6. Creamy Garlic Sauce
  • 7. Red Onion Gravy
  • 8. Marinara Sauce
  • 9. Pesto
  • 10. Sriracha Hot Sauce


  • Choose your favorite pick from the comprehensive selection provided in this article.
  • Gather all of the essential ingredients required for the recipe.
  • Prepare a delectable dish with your selected pick in under 30 minutes, following the provided instructions.
Keyword Sauces for Polenta to Consider
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating