Skip to Content

Sour Cream vs Mayo: What’s the Difference?

Do you ever find yourself walking down the condiment aisle at the grocery store and wondering what makes sour cream different than mayo?

Sure, one looks whiter and softer while the other is yellower and thicker…but what are their core differences?

The truth is that both have a unique place in culinary culture — but if asked to choose just one of these creamy ingredients for your sandwich or salad, chances are you’d appreciate having a deeper understanding of each.

In this blog post, we go beyond surface-level comparisons; we dive into the distinct taste profiles, production methods, cooking uses, health benefits (or drawbacks), plus much more.

By reading on further you’ll be able to answer definitively which option fits best into your meal plans.

What is Sour Cream?

Sour cream is a popular dairy product made from fermented cream.

It has a tangy taste and a creamy texture, making it versatile in many recipes.

This rich and thick condiment adds a unique twist to both sweet and savory dishes.

It’s made through fermenting regular cream with lactic acid bacteria.

This process gives it a tart flavor and a smooth texture.

The bacteria consume the lactose in milk, so sour cream has a lower lactose content than regular cream, making it easier to digest for those with lactose intolerance.

Sour cream enhances flavors and provides a creamy, luxurious texture to dishes.

It’s often used as a topping for soups, potatoes, tacos, and nachos.

Its acidity helps balance out rich or spicy flavors.

Another great feature of sour cream is its ability to make baked goods moist and tender.

When added to cake batters or bread doughs, it prevents them from drying out while baking.

It also adds richness to frostings and fillings.

Not only does sour cream have culinary uses, it also offers nutritional benefits.

It’s a good source of calcium and protein, important for healthy bones and muscles.

Plus, it contains vitamins A and D.

What is Mayo (Mayonnaise)?

Mayo, the shorthand for mayonnaise, is a yummy and zesty topping.

It’s made with oil, vinegar, lemon juice, and egg yolks that are blended together.

Its smooth texture and scrumptious taste make it a popular choice.

Mayo’s special combination of ingredients give it an incomparable flavor.

It’ll make your BLT sandwich and potato salad come to life.

With its creaminess and zing, mayo adds an extra something special to any dish.

Differences Between Sour Cream and Mayo

Sour cream and mayo are not just similar – they have differences.

Ingredients Used

Distinguishing between sour cream and mayo? Ingredients make all the difference.

Sour cream is made from fermented cream – giving it a tangy flavor and creamy texture.

Mayo is a blend of oil, eggs and vinegar or lemon juice which makes it smooth and rich.

Sour cream brings a tangy flavor to dishes.

Fermentation adds creaminess and acidity – great for dips, dressings and topping potatoes.

Mayo is known for its creamy texture. It’s created by combining oil, eggs and acidity.

A versatile condiment for sauces, spreads and dishes like coleslaw or pasta salad.

Sour cream and mayo have different qualities.

Sour cream is thicker – ideal for recipes needing moisture and density.

Mayo is lighter – ideal for recipes needing smoothness.

Texture and Consistency

Creamy, smooth, and velvety: these are the words that come to mind when talking about sour cream.

This yummy dairy product is known for its pleasing mouthfeel and its ability to give dishes a rich, tangy flavor.

The difference between sour cream and mayo? Sour cream is thicker and heavier, making it perfect for adding depth and richness to recipes.

Its smooth texture means it blends easily into dips, dressings, or even as a topping on potatoes.

Mayo, though creamy, is usually lighter.

This airy, silky consistency makes it great for spreading on sandwiches or using in salads.

It adds a gentle tanginess to food without overpowering other flavors.

These two condiments also differ in terms of ingredients.

Sour cream is made by fermenting heavy cream with lactic acid bacteria cultures, giving it its tangy taste.

Mayo is mainly oil, egg yolks, vinegar or lemon juice, and sometimes mustard.

So, whether you love the thick decadence of sour cream or the lightness of mayo, these condiments can both be used to enhance the flavor and texture of various dishes.

The choice is yours – don’t be afraid to experiment. You might just find your new favorite.

Flavor Profile

Sour cream and mayo, they look alike, but taste different.

Sour cream offers a rich and tangy flavor with a smooth texture.

It’s great for dishes like tacos or baked potatoes.

Mayo has a creamy and tangy taste.

It’s perfect to make sandwiches and salads even better.

Both give a creamy touch to food, but their unique flavors make them special.

Culinary Uses and Applications

Sour cream and mayo are two popular ingredients used in lots of cooking.

Sour cream adds tanginess and creaminess to toppings, dips, dressings and desserts.

It can also make baked goods like cakes and muffins yummier.

Mayo is great in sandwiches and salads because of its smooth taste.

It also helps make spreads like coleslaw or potato salad creamy.

It’s also a good base for sauces and marinades, adding flavor to meats and seafood.

Sour cream has a distinct tang, but mayo gives creaminess without taking over the other flavors.

Sour cream is often used in Mexican and Eastern European dishes.

Mayo is part of American classics like macaroni salad or deviled eggs.

Sour cream and mayo can be used instead of each other in recipes.

However, their consistencies and taste are different.

So, consider these when cooking to make amazing dishes.

Nutritional Comparison of Sour Cream and Mayo

Sour cream and mayo look alike, but they are not the same.

Sour cream is made from fermented cream and has a tangy taste.

Mayo is made from egg yolks and oil and has a creamy flavor.

Sour cream has more calories than mayo.

100 grams of sour cream is 206 calories. The same amount of mayo is 680 calories.

So, if you need to watch your calories, sour cream is the lighter option.

The source of fat also differs between the two.

Sour cream has more saturated fat because it comes from dairy.

Mayo has more unsaturated fat from the vegetable oil.

Sour cream contains more protein than mayo.

So, if you need extra protein, sour cream is the better choice.

Sour cream has calcium and vitamin A from the dairy.

Mayo doesn’t have any vitamins or minerals.

Similarities Between Sour Cream and Mayo

Sour cream and mayo? Similar, yet distinct.

Both creamy and add richness to dishes. But, ingredients and uses are different.

Sour cream comes from fermented cream with lactic acid bacteria.

Tangy flavor, thick consistency.

Enhances texture of dishes and adds a creamy element.

Mayonnaise? An emulsion of oil, egg yolks, and vinegar/lemon juice.

Smooth texture, mild taste. Can be used as dressing or sandwich spread.

Uses of sour cream and mayo differ. Sour cream on tacos/nachos.

Mayo in sandwiches/salads like coleslaw/potato salad. So, similar, yet distinct.

Knowing differences helps choose right ingredient to enhance culinary creations.

Substituting Sour Cream and Mayo in Recipes

Substituting sour cream and mayo? Consider their differences.

Sour cream is creamy, with a tangy flavor. Mayo is rich and slightly tangy.

Choice depends on desired outcome.

Sour cream adds luscious texture and subtle tartness.

Enhances flavors in baked goods or dressings.

Mayo provides creamy, smooth consistency.

Perfect for binding ingredients in salads or sandwiches.

Reduce fat content? Use Greek yogurt instead of sour cream.

Or use avocado instead of mayo. Offers healthier alternatives without compromising taste.


We’ve examined the differences between sour cream and mayonnaise, and on many levels.

Both can lend flavor, texture, and an unmistakable richness to any recipe.

Whether you opt for the dairy-based sour cream or an emulsification of oil and egg yolks that is mayonnaise, be sure to taste test your dishes to find out what works best for you.

No matter which one you choose, experimentation can take commonplace dishes from ordinary to extraordinary.

So get creative by swapping out one or the other in your recipes when a unique depth of flavor is desired.

And finally considering all these factors don’t forget to consult experts opinions on health nutrition guidance as they further effects your understanding of the effect of ingredients.

The real conclusion should always consider either way both come with their benefits and dangers hence go about things in a mindful manner.

Sour Cream vs Mayo: What’s the Difference?

Exploring the age-old debate of Sour Cream vs Mayo? Your quest for clarity ends here! Delve into the nuances and discover the key differences between these two popular condiments. Unravel the mysteries of taste, texture, and culinary applications to make an informed decision in your kitchen.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That
Servings 1 Serving


  • Sour Cream
  • Mayo


  • Choose between sour cream and mayo based on your taste preference and the dish you’re making.
  • Use sour cream for a tangy, creamy flavor, or mayo for a rich, slightly tangy taste.
  • Add your selected ingredient to your recipe in the amount specified or to taste.
  • Mix it in well to enhance the texture and flavor of your dish.
  • Enjoy your creation, and don’t hesitate to experiment with different recipes to discover your favorite choice!
Keyword Sour Cream vs Mayo
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating