Skip to Content

Enhance Recipes: 5 BEST Substitutes for Tomatoes

Hey there, food lovers! We’ve all had that moment—a recipe calls for tomatoes, and we’re fresh out. No tomatoes? No problem.

Today, we’re saving your kitchen with the 5 BEST substitutes for tomatoes. You’ll never have to pause your cooking again.

We’re here to keep your dishes delicious and your stress levels down. Think of us as your culinary superheroes, swooping in to rescue your meal.

With these swaps, bland and boring meals are off the menu. Get ready to meet some game-changing alternatives that will keep your flavors bold and your recipes on track.

Trust us, your dinner is about to get a major upgrade.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Tomatoes

You may be thinking you’re in trouble if you can’t find tomatoes for your dish, but there are some options.

You can even leave out tomatoes in some recipes.

Here’s a detailed comparison of the 5 best substitutes for tomatoes, along with their key characteristics and proper ratios:

SubstituteKey CharacteristicsProper Ratio
Canned TomatoesCanned tomatoes provide a similar flavor and texture to fresh tomatoes. They are widely used in cooking.Use an equal amount of canned tomatoes as you would with fresh tomatoes in recipes.
PumpkinPumpkin can be used as a substitute in certain recipes due to its mild sweetness and similar texture.Use half the amount of pumpkin puree as you would with tomatoes in recipes.
Bell PeppersBell peppers offer a crunchy texture and a mild, slightly sweet flavor that can substitute for tomatoes.Use an equal amount of finely chopped bell peppers as you would with tomatoes.
YogurtYogurt can add creaminess and tanginess to dishes. It can replace tomatoes in certain sauces and dressings.Use an equal amount of yogurt as you would with tomatoes in recipes.
MangoMango provides a tropical sweetness and juiciness that can be used in certain dishes as a tomato substitute.Use an equal amount of diced or pureed mango as you would with tomatoes in recipes.

Now, let’s discuss each substitute in more detail:

1 – Canned Tomatoes

canned tomatoes

There is nothing better than the real thing, and if you can’t find fresh tomatoes, you may have canned tomatoes already in your kitchen.

According to the USDA, canned tomatoes are eaten just as much as fresh tomatoes.

Canned tomatoes will not do much good in salads and sandwiches, as fresh tomatoes are definitely needed.

You can use them in any dish you are going to cook; just be aware that the canned version has a more robust flavor.

Canned tomatoes will do well in:

  • Pizzas.
  • Pasta.
  • Curries.
  • Sauces.
  • Soups.
  • Beans & Meats.

Canned tomatoes come in a few forms, including whole and diced.

Tomato puree has already been cooked, so you may not need to cook your food for as long.

2 – Pumpkin

pumpkin

This winter squash will probably already be in your pantry if you are out of tomatoes, so you can save yourself a trip to the store.

Pumpkins are incredibly healthy, being high in Vitamin A and other nutrients.

This squash is perfect for people on diets, and it boosts your immune system as well.

When you cook pumpkin, it has a similar texture and consistency to tomatoes, making it a good substitute for curries or stews.

If your dish needs tomatoes to be pureed, pumpkins are an excellent stand-in.

Pureed pumpkin is very similar to pureed tomatoes and will thicken and fill up the dish in the same way.

Suitable ratio:

Tomatoes and pumpkins vary in size considerably, so you need to measure the chopped or pureed form.

  • 1 cup chopped tomato= 1 cup chopped pumpkin.
  • 1 cup pureed tomato= 1 cup pureed pumpkin.

3 – Bell Peppers

bell peppers

Don’t worry about adding too much spice with this option; bell peppers are often called sweet peppers.

The best substitute for fresh tomatoes is red bell peppers.

Red bell peppers are the sweetest variety, and their color is also the same as tomatoes, so your salad won’t look much different.

Red bell peppers are used best as an alternate in recipes that require fresh tomatoes.

Salads that cannot use other options on this list can use bell peppers nicely.

Bell peppers also are great on sandwiches and burgers, especially when accompanied by a leafy vegetable.

Peppers have a much lower water content than tomatoes, which is important to think about when using them in cooking.

For example, if you are making pasta or curry, you may want to puree the bell peppers first.

Suitable ratio:

  • 1 large tomato= 1 bell pepper.
  • 1 cup tomato puree= 1 cup bell pepper puree.

4 – Yogurt

yogurt

You may be surprised to see yogurt on this list, but keep on reading.

Tomatoes are often used in food that needs to be thickened or as a base for a sauce, and yogurt can fill this same function if used carefully.

Indian curries often use tomatoes as a base; they thicken the liquid and make the dish savory.

You can also use yogurt in this way to provide body and tartness to the curry.

Use unsweetened yogurt for curries, homemade yogurt is the healthiest option.

Yogurt can also be used instead of tomatoes in thicker stews and similar dishes.

When using it in cooking, always try to add it as late as possible.

Suitable ratio:

  • 1 cup chopped tomatoes= 1 cup yogurt.

5 – Mango

mango

Here is another surprising entry to this list; you might think that mangoes are the opposite of tomatoes.

While ripe mangoes are very sweet, unripe mangoes have a slightly sour and tart taste.

Mangoes have a lovely, thick texture that can be used to thicken stews and curries, just like tomatoes.

It will be best to use slightly unripe mangoes for savory or spicy dishes so the sweetness does not interfere.

Fresh mango also goes nicely in salads.

The sweetness of the fruit will change the character of the salad, so choose your dressing carefully.

Suitable ratio:

  • 1 cup chopped tomatoes= 1 cup chopped mango.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Tomatoes

Searching for tomato substitutes? Your quest ends here! Explore our carefully curated list of the 5 best alternatives that seamlessly replace tomatoes in various dishes.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 4 Servings

Ingredients
  

  • Canned Tomatoes
  • Pumpkin
  • Bell Peppers
  • Yogurt
  • Mango

Instructions
 

  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword substitutes for tomatoes
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating