Skip to Content

Flavor Boost: 5 BEST Substitutes for Tuna

Got a hankering for tuna but your pantry’s signaling an SOS? No sweat!

You’re about to dive deep into the ocean of alternatives that’ll make your dishes sing without the star of the sea.

Sometimes, life throws a curveball and your go-to tuna can’t make it to the plate.

Good news is, the sea is big and so is your supermarket.

We’ve fished far and wide to net you the top 5 substitutes for tuna.

These swaps aren’t just good; they’re game-changers ready to slide into your recipes and steal the show.

Get ready to be wowed!

The 5 Best Substitutes for Tuna

If you’re looking for a sustainable seafood alternative to tuna, you’ve come to the right place.

Here are 5 of the best substitutes that offer a tasty and nutritious option:

1 – Salmon

Salmon is a truly intriguing fish.

Highly sought after, it spends part of its life cycle in salt water and part of it in fresh water, making it an anadromous creature.

Its flesh is especially orangey-pink in color – a hue that comes from its diet rich in crustaceans and natural carotenoids.

With its fatty yet delicate meat, salmon has a unique taste and texture unlike no other.

Despite being often referred to as “the tuna of the North,” salmon can be easily substituted for tuna in any dish due to its aesthetically pleasing look and flavor palette.

In short, this delectable fish should definitely not be overlooked.

2 – Trout

Trout is a species of freshwater fish that is collected from streams, rivers, and lakes.

They can also thrive in streams connected to the ocean and brackish water.

Compared to other fish, trout are known for their pink-orange meat and delicate texture.

Many people compare the taste of trout to that of tuna, making it a popular substitution when a recipe calls for it.

Trout flesh generally has a clean taste with medium oil levels and no fishy notes.

When cooked properly, the texture becomes very delicate and flaky, which helps to make up for the lack of flavor.

In order to substitute trout for tuna, simply select roasted or smoked varieties rather than canned, as this will give you a better-tasting product.

3 – Tilapia

Tilapia has caused quite a stir with its sudden popularity.

Once an obscure river fish, it’s now found in most supermarkets.

It has a mild, subtle flavor and delicate texture that is comparable to some saltwater fish like cod and halibut.

Tilapia is often referred to as the “poor man’s salmon” because it can be substituted for tuna or salmon in many dishes but costs substantially less.

It absorbs marinades quickly, cooks easily, and flakes apart nicely, making it an excellent choice for tacos and salads.

The versatility of this nutritious fish makes it a great choice regardless of whether you are on a limited budget or looking to try something new in the kitchen.

4 – Mahi Mahi

The seemingly unknown fish known as mahi mahi is surprisingly delicious and accessible.

It is a firm, aquatic fish native to tropical and temperate shallow seas but can also be found in food store aisles with relative ease.

This makes it an excellent choice for the home chef.

Taste-wise, it carries a sweet flavor and mildly delicate texture, allowing it to suit either slow-cooking techniques or light-fried dishes.

It’s mostly known as an ideal substitute for tuna due to its flaky yet tenacious consistency that won’t fall apart during cooking.

Alongside its robust versatility, this makes mahi mahi a fish for all occasions.

5 – Pollock

Pollock, a sea-dwelling species of fish, is an interesting delicacy.

It has a very distinct flavor and texture that separates it from many other types of seafood.

Pollock’s flesh tends to have a mild, buttery taste and a soft, tender texture which make it popular amongst chefs and seafood aficionados alike.

It can be cooked in numerous ways, such as steamed, fried, or grilled, but when boiled, it takes on a chunkier consistency somewhat reminiscent of canned tuna.

Due to this, it is often used as an alternative for replacing canned tuna in recipes such as salads or casseroles, where it provides a healthier and more flavorful option than its preserved counterpart.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Tuna

Whether you're looking to switch up your tuna salad or need a replacement for a tuna-based dish, these five substitutes offer similar taste and texture profiles to satisfy your craving.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Salmon
  • Trout
  • Tilapia
  • Mahi Mahi
  • Pollock


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword Substitutes for Tuna
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating