Skip to Content

Gourmet Hacks: 5 BEST Substitutes for White Cheddar

Alright, folks, we’ve all been there.

You’re in the kitchen, ready to whip up something delicious, and bam, no white cheddar in sight.

Major bummer, right? Well, hold on to your aprons because we have some killer swaps that’ll save your dish and maybe, just maybe, make it even better.

From gooey melts to sharp bites, these substitutes are about to become your new best friends in the cheese aisle.

Get ready to say goodbye to cheese panic and hello to flavor town adventures with these top-notch picks.

What’s White Cheddar?

White cheddar is a unique cheese that brings its own flavor to the table.

It has a creamy and savory taste, with a subtle sharpness added as it ages.

The texture is smooth and delightfully firm, making it a great choice for melting and cooking.

White cheddar can be used in dishes like omelets, macaroni, and cheese or even melted on meat sandwiches to add an extra punch of flavor.

Although it confuses many people due to its off-white color, white cheddar is actually just regular cheddar that hasn’t been colored orange with annatto, a natural dye derived from the seeds of the Annatto tree known as Achiote.

This perplexity makes white cheddar one of the most interesting cheeses on the market.

The 5 BEST Substitutes for White Cheddar

If you’re a fan of white cheddar, you know that it’s the perfect balance of sharp and creamy.

But sometimes, you just can’t find it at the store.

Or maybe you’re looking for a change.

Whatever the reason, we’ve got you covered with the five best substitutes for white cheddar.

1 – Yellow Cheddar

The enigmatic yet captivating hue of yellow cheddar cheese is a cherished sight to behold.

This charming shade of yellow originates from the addition of annatto, derived from the achiote tree.

The unique flavor of yellow cheddar offers a balanced, mildly sharp taste and slightly crumbly texture that mellows when melted.

With its bold color and taste, yellow cheddar cheese is perfect for topping tacos, enchiladas, and omelets.

If you use it instead of white cheddar in your favorite recipes, you will be rewarded with an intensely flavorful dish.

2 – Edam Cheese

Edam cheese is an intriguing, lesser-known cheese that leaves foodie enthusiasts perplexed in the very best way.

It has a semi-hard, compact texture and a buttery, nutty, slightly sweet flavor.

Unlike cheddar, Edam cheese won’t go rubbery once melted, making it perfect for raclette or adding to gratins and fondues.

Moreover, this nutty cheese also works as an excellent substitute in mac and cheese dishes that call for white cheddar.

Instead of chasing down hard-to-find ingredients or sticking with the tried-and-true cheddar variety, you can easily elevate your meals with the buttery flavors of Edam cheese.

3 – Gouda Cheese

Gouda cheese has been a favorite across the world for centuries.

This Dutch-style, semi-hard cheese is made from pasteurized cow’s milk, giving it its unique creamy texture.

Gouda is known for its rich and nutty flavor, which is often enhanced by aging.

The longer it is aged, the more intense its taste becomes.

Its firm texture makes it ideal for slicing and grating, making it a great addition to sandwiches and salads.

If you’re in need of a substitution for white cheddar, Gouda could be the perfect alternative due to its similar taste and texture.

Moreover, Gouda can be melted on top of macaroni or thrown into an omelet – just make sure you cut some off an hour before cooking so that it can reach room temperature first.

4 – Gruyére Cheese

Baffling many, Gruyere cheese is a complex and unique cheese that can be enjoyed both on its own and as part of a decadent dish.

Originating from France, it’s nutty in flavor but also slightly sweet with a smooth texture.

This Swiss-style cheese melts easily and makes for an excellent appetizer when paired with some crackers or French bread for dipping.

Its creamy consistency pairs brilliantly with stews and baking dishes alike, adding oomph to whatever recipe you choose to stir into.

For those looking for a more tangy experience than what you’d receive from white cheddar, try subbing in some Gruyere while making macaroni – the result will be unforgettable.

5 – Colby Cheese

Colby cheese has been raising eyebrows and palates since it was first created in the late nineteenth century.

The history of Colby cheese is closely intertwined with that of Colby, Wisconsin, where it was originally made.

The cheese’s unique orange colored exterior and marbled consistency make it visually distinctive from other cheeses like white cheddar.

Upon tasting, Colby has a mild flavor and soft texture, providing a subtly sweeter flavor than white cheddar.

While it can be enjoyed as an appetizer or melted into grilled sandwiches, Colby makes an excellent substitute for white cheddar in traditional dishes, such as macaroni and cheese.

Its soft consistency and subtle sweetness give complexity to many recipes beyond what white cheddar alone would provide.


In conclusion, white cheddar may be the traditional cheese for many dishes, but there are plenty of other types of cheeses that can make equally delicious substitutions.

From the nutty flavor of Edam to the creamy sweetness of Colby, you can easily find an alternative to fit your tastes and preferences.

Whether you’re looking for a subtler addition or something with a bolder flavor, these five substitutes for white cheddar can offer an excellent variety of flavors and textures.

So next time you find yourself reaching for the same cheese, try something new – your taste buds won’t regret it.

The 5 BEST Substitutes for White Cheddar

Looking for a substitute for white cheddar cheese in your recipes? Look no further! Discover our top 5 picks for alternatives that will offer a similar creamy texture and sharp flavor to your dishes.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Substitutes
Servings 1 Serving


  • Yellow Cheddar
  • Edam Cheese
  • Gouda Cheese
  • Gruyére Cheese
  • Colby Cheese


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.
Keyword Substitutes for White Cheddar
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating