Skip to Content

The 5 Best Substitutes for Yellow Mustard

5 from 1 vote Only logged in users can rate recipes

Think about your favorite sandwich for a minute.

Is it grilled cheese with American cheese and yellow mustard? A BLT with mayo and yellow mustard?

A turkey club with yellow mustard and honey mustard? Whatever it is, you probably can’t imagine eating it without yellow mustard.

But what is yellow mustard, and how did it become such a staple condiment?

In addition, what are the best substitutes for yellow mustard that can give your sandwich that same flavor profile?

What is Yellow Mustard?

Anyone who has ever eaten a hot dog or potato salad knows the distinctive taste of yellow mustard.

But what exactly is this condiment, and where did it come from?

Yellow mustard is a type of prepared mustard that is typically made from a mixture of ground mustard seeds, vinegar, water, and spices.

The mustard seeds are responsible for the characteristic sharp flavor, while the vinegar and spices add depth and complexity.

The exact ingredients and proportions vary depending on the brand, but most commercial varieties contain turmeric, which gives them their characteristic yellow color.

Though it is now ubiquitous in the United States, yellow mustard was actually born in Europe.

Early versions were likely made with wine or verjuice instead of vinegar, and they were used more as a medical remedy than a food item.

It wasn’t until the 19th century that mustard began to be mass-produced and sold as a condiment.

At first, it was primarily used as an ingredient in other dishes, such as deviled eggs and vinaigrettes.

But by the early 20th century, it had become a popular spread for sandwiches and another simple fare.

Today, yellow mustard is one of the most commonly used condiments in the world.

Its sharp flavor pairs well with savory foods like hot dogs and hamburgers, but it can also add a touch of brightness to salads or roasted vegetables.

And because it is so versatile, yellow mustard is an essential ingredient in many favorite recipes.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Yellow Mustard

If you’re out of yellow mustard and need a substitution for a recipe, try one of these five substitutes.

1 – Dijon Mustard

Dijon mustard is a type of mustard that originates from the French city of Dijon.

It is typically made with brown or black mustard seeds, vinegar, and wine, and it has a sharp, tangy flavor.

The texture of Dijon mustard can vary depending on the brand, but it is usually smooth and creamy.

When substituting Dijon mustard for yellow mustard in a recipe, keep in mind that it will add a bit more complexity to the flavor.

Yellow mustard is more mellow and slightly sweet, while Dijon mustard is tangier and has a bit of a bite.

However, both mustards can be used in many of the same dishes, such as chicken salad or deviled eggs.

With its rich flavor and versatility, Dijon mustard is a pantry staple that belongs in every kitchen.

2 – Brown Mustard

Brown mustard is a type of mustard seed that is smaller and hotter than the more common yellow mustard seed.

It has a sharp, pungent flavor that is often used in pickling recipes.

Brown mustard seeds can also be ground into a powder and used as a spice rub for meats.

When substituting brown mustard for yellow mustard, it is important to use less of it since it is more potent.

You may also need to add a little sugar or honey to balance out the heat.

Overall, brown mustard is a great way to add some extra flavor to your dishes.

3 – Honey Mustard

Honey mustard is a type of salad dressing made from honey and mustard.

It is popular in the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom.

The taste of honey mustard varies depending on the ratio of honey to mustard used but is generally sweet with a tangy kick.

The texture is thick and creamy, similar to that of mayonnaise.

Honey mustard can be used as a substitution for yellow mustard in many recipes.

It is often used in sandwiches, as a dip for chicken or pork, or as a glaze for ham or fish.

Honey mustard is also a common ingredient in salads and coleslaw.

For a sweeter flavor, try using honey mustard dressing instead of vinaigrette.

You can also use it to make a marinade for grilling or roasting meats.

4 – Spicy Mustard

Spicy mustard is a type of mustard that is prepared with the addition of chili peppers or other spices.

It can range in color from bright yellow to deep brown, and the flavor can vary from mild to extremely hot.

The texture of spicy mustard is usually smooth, although some brands may contain whole mustard seeds or pieces of chili pepper.

Spicy mustard can be used as a substitute for yellow mustard in many recipes.

It can add a unique flavor to sandwiches, burgers, hot dogs, and even potato salad.

If you are looking for a more robust flavor, try using spicy mustard in place of ketchup or mayonnaise.

Just be sure to taste the recipe before serving, as the spice level can vary greatly between brands.

5 – Wasabi

Wasabi is a culinary delight that originates from Japan.

It has a unique taste and texture that sets it apart from other condiments.

Wasabi is often used as a substitute for yellow mustard, as it has a similar spicy flavor profile.

However, wasabi is also significantly hotter than mustard, making it perfect for those who enjoy a little bit of spice in their food.

In addition to its piquant flavor, wasabi also has a creamy texture that makes it perfect for spreading on sandwiches or using as a dip.

Whether you enjoy it on its own or as a replacement for mustard, wasabi is sure to add some zing to your next meal.


In conclusion, Yellow mustard is a great condiment with a versatile flavor that can be used in many dishes.

If you are looking for a substitution for yellow mustard, try one of the following: Dijon mustard, brown mustard, honey mustard, spicy mustard, or wasabi.

Each of these condiments will add its own unique flavor to your dish, so be sure to choose one that best suits your taste.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Yellow Mustard

Recipe by Andrew Gray Course: Substitutes


Prep time


Cooking time


Total time




  • Dijon Mustard

  • Brown Mustard

  • Honey Mustard

  • Spicy Mustard

  • Wasabi


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.

Recipe Video

About The Author

The 5 Best Substitutes for Sulguni Cheese