Skip to Content

Baking Essentials: 5 Great Golden Caster Sugar Substitutes

5 from 1 vote Only logged in users can rate recipes

Have you ever wondered what makes Golden Caster Sugar so special?

This is not the same as white caster sugar or regular granulated sugar but rather a type of sugar made from partially refined cane sugar that contains more than 50% sucrose.

It has finer crystals, creating a more desirable texture while baking.

If you’re out of golden caster sugar, however, there are some great substitutes to consider.

From coconut sugar to honey and brown sugar, there are plenty of ways to substitute golden caster sugar into almost any recipe.

What is Golden Caster Sugar?

Golden caster sugar is a deliciously sweet alternative to regular white granulated sugar.

Its soft and velvety texture comes from its finer grain size, which makes it perfect for baking and giving cakes, biscuits, and desserts an extra special touch.

Despite its name, golden caster sugar does not have any added coloring or flavoring – its light golden hue is due to the amount of larger-sized particles present that give the sugar a more caramel-like flavor.

Originating in England during the late 18th century, this type of sugar was originally used only by professional bakers who loved its smooth finish when used to dust over the tops of their baked goods.

Nowadays, it’s much more accessible to use in your own kitchen creations.

Golden caster sugar easily dissolves into liquids, making it great for all kinds of recipes such as custards, puddings, ice cream bases, jams, and jellies – even drinks like cocktails or tea can benefit from a teaspoonful of this sweet treat.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Golden Caster Sugar

If you’re looking for a substitution for golden caster sugar, you’re in luck.

There are many substitutions that can be used to replace Golden Caster Sugar and still achieve the same desired flavor and texture results.

Here are five of our favorite alternatives:

1 – Superfine Sugar

Superfine sugar sometimes called Baker’s extra-fine or castor sugar, is a type of processed sugar produced by breaking down large grains of traditionally extracted cane sugar.

The ultra-fine granules are smaller than those of other sugars, giving the finished product an almost impalpable texture and almost undetectable taste.

Because of its subtle flavor profile and delicate size, superfine sugar can often be substituted for golden castor sugar in most recipes.

Bakers will find it especially useful in meringues and chiffons, where even consistency is key.

2 – Coconut Sugar

Coconut sugar is a natural sweetener that is quickly gaining popularity all over the world.

It has an earthy taste and a gritty texture, which makes it stand out from other sugars, such as golden caster sugar.

Coconut sugar also has a slightly lower glycemic index than normal refined table sugar.

So if you are looking for healthier ways to add sweetness to your recipes, you might want to give coconut sugar a try.

You can even use the same amount of coconut sugar as the recipe calls for in golden caster sugar for cakes and cookies, with no negative effect on the final result.

However, bear in mind that coconut sugar does not have quite the same level of sweetness as regular white caster sugar, so make sure you adjust accordingly by adding 25 – 35% more than what your recipe requires.

3 – Brown Sugar

Brown sugar has a unique flavor and texture compared to golden caster sugar.

It is slightly stickier and has subtle hints of molasses in its flavor- it’s sweeter but is not as intense as that of the golden caster.

Brown sugar can be easily substituted for the golden caster—just be sure to use the same amount or slightly more if you want extra sweetness.

You can also make your own brown sugar if needed; simply mix together one cup of white sugar with a tablespoon of molasses for each cup of sugar used.

This easy substitution will help you get your desired sweetness levels every time.

4 – Maple Syrup

Maple syrup is, without a doubt, one of the most delicious natural sweeteners around.

Its golden texture and delightful taste offer a unique flavor that is different from regular sugar.

It is often used as a topping over pancakes, French toast, and waffles but can also be used to add sweetness to other dishes like oatmeal, yogurt, or even cooked carrots.

Maple syrup can actually be used as an alternative to golden caster sugar when baking cakes or cookies; simply use half the amount of caster sugar you normally would and replace it with an equal amount of maple syrup.

The end result will be moist and tantalizing treats that have just the perfect hint of sweetness.

5 – Honey

Honey is an amazing natural sweetener, treasured for its distinct flavor and its many health benefits.

It has a unique taste that’s at once lightly floral, a bit earthy, and far sweeter than white table sugar.

Its texture is thicker than most other sugars, making it delicious in recipes like honey-glazed baked goods or sauces.

Honey can be substituted one-to-one with golden caster sugar when baking, though it will affect the final consistency – as well as give your goods an extra layer of flavor.

Try using it in recipes for pancakes and muffins for something sweet and nourishing you’ll love devouring.


In conclusion, there are a number of great alternatives for golden caster sugar that can bring their own unique flavor or sweetness to your cooking and baking.

Coconut sugar, brown sugar, maple syrup, and honey each have their own distinct flavor profiles, textures, and health benefits which make them good substitutes for golden caster sugar.

Experiment with all these ingredients until you find the one that works best for your recipes.

With the right combination, you can have delicious treats that are sure to make everyone in your household drool.

The 5 Best Substitutes for Golden Caster Sugar

Recipe by Andrew Gray Course: Substitutes


Prep time


Cooking time


Total time




  • Superfine Sugar

  • Coconut Sugar

  • Brown Sugar

  • Maple Syrup

  • Honey


  • Pick your favorite substitute from the list above.
  • Follow cooking directions for your selected substitute with the proper ratio of ingredients.

Recipe Video

About The Author