Skip to Content

Membrillo vs Guayaba: What’s the Difference?

Ever found yourselves staring at the exotic fruit section and scratching your heads? Membrillo and guayaba sit there, almost mocking our confusion. They’re not the same, folks.

Membrillo, or quince, is a tough cookie. It’s hard and not very friendly when raw. On the other side, guayaba, or guava, is the chill cousin. Soft, sweet, and ready to eat.

We learned this the hard way. A tart quince pie was the unexpected result of our mix-up. Lesson learned.

So, grab a knife. We’re cutting into this mystery, once and for all.

What is Membrillo?

Membrillo, also known as quince paste, is a delectable sweet spread made from the fruit of the quince tree.

This fragrant fruit is not widely eaten raw due to its bitter and grainy texture, but the cooked down version turns into a sticky and intensely flavored preserve that pairs well with cheese and cured meats.

  • Membrillo is a Spanish delicacy that has been enjoyed for centuries.
  • It is made by cooking quince fruit in sugar and water until it thickens and turns into a soft paste.
  • This versatile treat can be consumed as a dessert or used as an accompaniment to savory dishes like chicken or pork.
  • Due to its high pectin content, it can also be used in baking as a substitute for jams or jellies.

One interesting fact about membrillo is that it has been used traditionally as a remedy for digestive issues and sore throats.

It is also rich in vitamins C and A, along with potassium and fiber.

Its flavor profile is complex, ranging from floral notes to tartness depending on ripeness.

Overall, membrillo offers a unique taste experience that is vastly different from other fruit pastes like guayaba.

What is Guayaba?

Guayaba is a tropical fruit that is native to Central and South America.

Also known as guava, it has a green or yellow skin and a delicate aroma.

The flesh of the fruit has numerous small seeds in the center and is creamy white or pink.

Guayaba is commonly used in jams, jellies, candies, and beverages due to its sweet flavor and high nutritional value.

Apart from its culinary uses, guayaba also serves as a natural remedy for various health problems.

It is believed to boost immunity, improve digestion, lower blood sugar levels, and prevent cancer.

In traditional medicine practices, its leaves are commonly used to treat diarrhea and dysentery.

Overall, guayaba’s versatile uses make it an important fruit in many cultures around the world.

From being consumed raw or cooked to being used for medicinal purposes, it continues to be a sought-after fruit.

Differences Between Membrillo and Guayaba

Membrillo and Guayaba are two different fruits known for their unique flavors and nutritional benefits.

Despite some similarities, these fruits have several differences that set them apart.

Appearance and Texture

The physical attributes that distinguish membrillo from guayaba are quite apparent.

Both fruits have a distinctively different appearance and texture, despite belonging to the same family of Rosaceae.

Membrillo is yellow in color; its skin has a rough texture and appears to be less shiny than guayaba’s bright green outer layer.

The flesh of membrillo possesses a waxy texture while that of guayaba is soft in comparison, with an abundance of small seeds embedded within.

Flavor Profile

The flavors of Membrillo and Guayaba are distinct from one another.

The taste profile of Membrillo carries a unique sweetness with slight tartness that is reminiscent of a cross between an apple and a pear.

In contrast, the flavor profile of Guayaba is considered to be more tropical in nature, with sweet notes akin to pineapple or mango combined with subtle floral undertones.

Both fruits can be used in cooking and baking to add a unique twist to dishes.

Culinary Uses

Both membrillo and guayaba are popular choices in the culinary world, known for their distinctive flavors and versatile nature.

While membrillo is commonly used in making jams, jellies and pastes, guayaba is often used to make beverages, candies, and desserts.

When it comes to using membrillo for culinary purposes, it can be sliced on top of cheese or eaten as a sweet snack all by itself.

Additionally, it can be roasted and perfectly paired with grilled meats like pork or beef.

On the other hand, guayaba fruit is typically used for baking; often blended into a paste that goes great as an ingredient for pies and cakes.

It’s worth noting that these fruits have different nutritional values – while guayabas contain more vitamin C than many citrus fruits; membrillos are rich in fiber along with other vitamins like potassium which help aid your digestion system.

At the end of the day, both fruits are versatile enough to be used in a wide range of dishes – from salads to stews – leaving ample room for experimentation.

No matter what you choose to create with them, from classic recipes to innovative twists; whether as appetizers or desserts – both membrillo and guayaba make fine companions for the discerning chef.

Similarities Between Membrillo and Guayaba

Both Membrillo and Guayaba are common fruits with a few similarities:

  • They both originate from the same family – Myrtaceae family.
  • They have similar textures and are used to prepare jams, jellies and other preserves. Finally, both of them contain several essential vitamins like Vitamin C.

Membrillo and Guayaba are also different in many ways.

Unlike Guayaba, Membrillo has a distinct aroma and is popularly used to make quince jelly or paste.

Guayaba is much sweeter than Membrillo and has a honey-like flavour with small seeds inside it.

Moreover, Guayaba can be consumed raw while Membrillo needs to be cooked before consumption.

It’s interesting to note that even though Membrillo and Guayaba have some similarities, they possess a plethora of unique characteristics that make them taste completely different.

Health Benefits of Membrillo and Guayaba

Membrillo and Guayaba are two fruits that are often compared to each other.

These fruits differentiate in terms of their taste, texture, and nutritional value.

Here, we’ll explore the health benefits of each fruit.

  • Membrillo is a rich source of dietary fiber, antioxidants, vitamin C, potassium, iron and copper.
  • Guayaba is rich in vitamin C, fiber, folate, potassium and antioxidants.
  • The consumption of Membrillo supports digestion by improving bowel movements and relieving constipation.
  • The consumption of Guayaba strengthens the immune system.

Apart from these general health benefits there are a few unique details about these two fruits worth noting.

While both can be consumed fresh or made into jams or jellys, guayaba is best eaten on an empty stomach while membrillo pairs well with cheese.

Incorporating both fruits into one’s diet promotes overall health by boosting nutrient intake.

Where to Find Membrillo and Guayaba?

Looking for the difference between Membrillo and Guayaba? Both fruits could be found in various grocers and markets globally.

  • Membrillo can primarily be found in Latin America.
  • You can spot Guayaba across South Asia, Latin America, and Africa.
  • You can purchase both fruits from local Hispanic supermarkets.
  • Certain online fruit retailers and importers offer freeze-dried, dried guava or Quince paste.
  • Farmers markets are more available sources for both fruits especially during the growing season.
  • Consider checking out specialty food stores where you might come across fresh options as well as canned pulp of both fruits.

Interestingly, since both fruits belong to the same family- Myrtaceae-, they have similar nutritional values like fiber content but differ greatly in flavor profiles.


While both membrillo and guayaba are popular fruits in Latin America, they are distinct from each other in several ways.

Membrillo, also known as quince, has a tart and slightly sweet flavor while guayaba, also known as guava, has a very sweet and tropical taste.

In terms of appearance, membrillo is yellowish-green with a rough skin that needs to be peeled before eating.

Guayaba, on the other hand, has a green or yellow skin that is edible but the seeds need to be removed.

While both fruits can be used in cooking and baking, membrillo is often used to make jams and pastes while guayaba is used for desserts like pies and ice creams.

Overall, it is important to understand the differences between these two fruits before using them in recipes to ensure the best possible outcome.

Membrillo vs Guayaba: What’s the Difference?

Andrew Gray
Curious about the distinction between membrillo and guayaba? Delve into the nuances between these two fruits to understand their flavor profiles, textures, and culinary applications.
5 from 2 votes
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course This vs That


  • Membrillo
  • Guayaba


  • Choose between membrillo and guayaba based on your preference and availability.
  • Follow the recommended instructions for your chosen fruit, considering the specific preparation methods.
  • Prepare the membrillo or guayaba by peeling, coring, and removing any unwanted parts.
  • Process the fruit according to your desired recipe, whether it involves cooking, pureeing, or preserving.
  • Adjust the sweetness or seasoning as desired, ensuring the flavor profile suits your taste.
  • Incorporate the membrillo or guayaba into your dishes or enjoy them as standalone treats.
  • Embrace the unique characteristics of each fruit and explore their diverse culinary uses.
  • Experiment with different recipes and techniques to fully appreciate the versatility of membrillo and guayaba.
Keyword Membrillo vs Guayaba
Did you make this recipe?Mention @AmericasRestaurant or tag #americasrestaurant!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating